Go cabrio I think that aqua blue coupe will have poor resale. That's not a particularly good color for resale. A white cabrio on the otherhand is a hot selling car. I'm a bit biased as I have to have a rag top, even though I'm in Michigan and can only use it about 5 months a year.
Good luck and let us know and post pics.

 

What he said - Costco has great prices on Extended Warranties....

 

+991, looks better in coupe form plus aqua blue is beautiful, if you want a convertible, get the new boxster, great looking car.

 

It goes both ways, not everyone wants silver, black, and white cars. The rare time a blue one hits the market, it gets picked up quickly. Can't say the same about new cars, blue sits on the lot forever. I guess all blue car buyers are bargain hunters.

 

It seems like car # 2 is the better deal. Remember that you have a couple of choices about warranty.
1. the dealer will CPO the car for around $3000
2. you have the remainder of the factory warranty to purchase a 3rd party warranty that your dealer will sell you.
Good Luck!