91 octane 0 ethanol vs 94 octane 10% ethanol
#16
Torco is an octane booster in a can. There are a lot of bull**** octane boosters that you can get at autozone or whatever, but Torco is one of the few legitimate ones. I did a ton of research on it. It is popular with the supercharged corvette crowd. One even mixed a tank and sent some of the fuel in to be tested at an octane testing lab and confirmed it's worth. My car runs much stronger on Torco. Only downside is that it leaves a yellowish powder coat in your exhaust, but I haven't heard of anyone having any real problems with the product. I run it all the time. Give the quart can a try. http://torcoracefuel.net/1-pix-torco...or-bottles.jpg
I have had good luck with just NOS booster on the dyno with bike motors.
#17
Well my tuner said that my 91 log provides slightly better timing than the 94 does. Along with a little more fuel quantity. The 94 required more short term trim than the 91.
Whatever that means...... I asked him what the conclusion was. haha.
Whatever that means...... I asked him what the conclusion was. haha.
#19
This is really old school thinking with a lot of incorrect information stated. 91 octane with 10% ethanol vs 91 octane without ethanol will have negligible performance differences. It has to do with a cleaner burn and that to me is a good thing for the masses.
Max we talked about some of this on the phone but I will add some more here that I think we did not cover.
I tried once before several days ago but I pressed send and the page disappeared.
Alcohol fuel is bad on different levels and so many.
It is dry fuel with poor lubrication properties, you may not think that is a big deal as your engine has oil in it but it is also a solvent that strips away that lubrication. So in the absence of oil and the fuel having poor lubrication properties that dries things out you have a recipe for accelerated engine wear; also store an engine running alcohol fuel for any time and you have potential for stuck valves, rings and such.
Alcohol fuels do not store well as they are hydrophilic; meaning they absorb water.
Alcohol is added for environmental reasons not because it makes a better fuel, Small amounts of alcohol in a fuel adds the appearance of better octane ratings when in fact it is all smoke and mirrors as the constituent elements that would make alcohol enriched fuel better are too costly to add for a company that is just concerned with meeting minimum standards and making a profit.
Alcohol fuel has a lower enthalpy of heat then a regular premium fuel. What that means is per a certain volume it has less energy. To get the same amount of energy you need more of it.
The specific gravity of alcohol enriched fuel changes more with temperature. And living in a country like Canada where 70 degree temp changes during the course of a day are a regular occurrence for many months it is harder to tune an engine for consistent performance.
Alcohol enriched fuels may evaporate easier but they have a lower heat of vaporization, The higher a fuel’s heat of vaporization, the better its ability to cool the intake mixture which is a bonus for making power.
Alcohol enriched fuel burns slower, hence why some engines are good at pulling back timing to allow them to burn more completely. So many people think that is an indication that there engine is making more power but in reality it is only trying to burn the fuel that is yielding LESS power... The alcohol enriched fuels we get continue to burn past 20 deg ATDC (After Top Dead Center) which adds nothing to the overall power output of an engine.
The fact is these low alcohol fuels are missing the those expensive components to make them something other than some environmental propaganda.
Now this is just a very very basic over view of why I do not like alcohol enriched fuel, a person could write a book on the subject and still not do it justice.
That is the nature of alcohol fuels for many reasons but some of them are above. Just because you added timing does not make them better.
Alcohol enriched fuels are hog wash forced on us from states like California that have the people power to effect and entire continent.
I tried once before several days ago but I pressed send and the page disappeared.
Alcohol fuel is bad on different levels and so many.
It is dry fuel with poor lubrication properties, you may not think that is a big deal as your engine has oil in it but it is also a solvent that strips away that lubrication. So in the absence of oil and the fuel having poor lubrication properties that dries things out you have a recipe for accelerated engine wear; also store an engine running alcohol fuel for any time and you have potential for stuck valves, rings and such.
Alcohol fuels do not store well as they are hydrophilic; meaning they absorb water.
Alcohol is added for environmental reasons not because it makes a better fuel, Small amounts of alcohol in a fuel adds the appearance of better octane ratings when in fact it is all smoke and mirrors as the constituent elements that would make alcohol enriched fuel better are too costly to add for a company that is just concerned with meeting minimum standards and making a profit.
Alcohol fuel has a lower enthalpy of heat then a regular premium fuel. What that means is per a certain volume it has less energy. To get the same amount of energy you need more of it.
The specific gravity of alcohol enriched fuel changes more with temperature. And living in a country like Canada where 70 degree temp changes during the course of a day are a regular occurrence for many months it is harder to tune an engine for consistent performance.
Alcohol enriched fuels may evaporate easier but they have a lower heat of vaporization, The higher a fuel’s heat of vaporization, the better its ability to cool the intake mixture which is a bonus for making power.
Alcohol enriched fuel burns slower, hence why some engines are good at pulling back timing to allow them to burn more completely. So many people think that is an indication that there engine is making more power but in reality it is only trying to burn the fuel that is yielding LESS power... The alcohol enriched fuels we get continue to burn past 20 deg ATDC (After Top Dead Center) which adds nothing to the overall power output of an engine.
The fact is these low alcohol fuels are missing the those expensive components to make them something other than some environmental propaganda.
Now this is just a very very basic over view of why I do not like alcohol enriched fuel, a person could write a book on the subject and still not do it justice.
That is the nature of alcohol fuels for many reasons but some of them are above. Just because you added timing does not make them better.
Alcohol enriched fuels are hog wash forced on us from states like California that have the people power to effect and entire continent.
#20
Well the proof is in my logs. Todd at proto looked at my logs and the conclusion is that the 0 ethanol 91 showed better results than the 10% ethanol 94 octane.
#21
Care to elaborate?
Last edited by Engine Guy; 05-09-2012 at 02:29 PM.
#22
OK a couple of things. You imply alcohol has a lower heat of vaporation than gasoline and less of a cooling effect--not true. Alcohol has a higher heat of vaporization and much better cooling effect than gas. You also state that alcohol makes less power but when in fact, it's just the opposite. Alcohol is able to generate more power because you can burn more fuel which creates greater combustion pressures, i.e. worse fuel mileage but more power. Cars in Brazil have been running on alcohol for years due to all the sugar cane production. Gas has just been more convenient for us.
#23
OK a couple of things. You imply alcohol has a lower heat of vaporation than gasoline and less of a cooling effect--not true. Alcohol has a higher heat of vaporization and much better cooling effect than gas. You also state that alcohol makes less power but when in fact, it's just the opposite. Alcohol is able to generate more power because you can burn more fuel which creates greater combustion pressures, i.e. worse fuel mileage but more power. Cars in Brazil have been running on alcohol for years due to all the sugar cane production. Gas has just been more convenient for us.
Absolutlely and completely wrong about alcohols heat of vaporization. and regular fuel. Now you can add chemicals to alcohol that change the properties to raise that number. Alcohol does not add more power because you can burn more, it does require more fuel to equal the same amount of thermal units per a certain volume of non alcohol enriched gas though.
I do not know about the chemistry of brazillian fuel but here in North America alcohol enriched fuels are legislated due to government policy; not performance or economic viability; and due to environmental reasons the fuel makers do not use certain chemicals that actually make alcohol enriched fuels a better performance product. Now I am not talking E85 which can be considered a cheap performance fuel; but that is no smoking gun either as a car needs some costly modifications to run the stuff.
Fuel chemistry is a subject that is debated by many an internet expert yet it is understood by so few (Heck I could be one of those un knowing ***** for all anyone here knows) but I can say for a fact that my money goes on good non alcohol enriched fuel. If I want the extra octane I mix race gas into the equation or even use Torco additive.
Sorry Edit.... As most here will not know this... The Torco fuel accelerator died with Torco going under but a product called Green Trail Accelerator is the same product.
Don't trust me ask everyones buddy Jay
http://www.jaylenosgarage.com/video/...-fuel/1288164/
Last edited by Engine Guy; 05-09-2012 at 05:43 PM.
#24
He did not quote what he read on the pump, Todd is a tuner that read his durametric log from his engine during a staged test with the two different fuels. The 91 no alcohol fuel was found to be a better performer due to as a result of looking at the engine parameters.
Absolutlely and completely wrong about alcohols heat of vaporization. and regular fuel. Now you can add chemicals to alcohol that change the properties to raise that number. Alcohol does not add more power because you can burn more, it does require more fuel to equal the same amount of thermal units per a certain volume of non alcohol enriched gas though.
E85 produces more power than gas, that's a given. As for why alcohol produces more power, it has to do with the combustion process.
Couldn't agree more.
Last edited by TTdude; 05-09-2012 at 11:52 PM.
#25
Max we talked about some of this on the phone but I will add some more here that I think we did not cover.
I tried once before several days ago but I pressed send and the page disappeared.
Alcohol fuel is bad on different levels and so many.
It is dry fuel with poor lubrication properties, you may not think that is a big deal as your engine has oil in it but it is also a solvent that strips away that lubrication. So in the absence of oil and the fuel having poor lubrication properties that dries things out you have a recipe for accelerated engine wear; also store an engine running alcohol fuel for any time and you have potential for stuck valves, rings and such.
Alcohol fuels do not store well as they are hydrophilic; meaning they absorb water.
Alcohol is added for environmental reasons not because it makes a better fuel, Small amounts of alcohol in a fuel adds the appearance of better octane ratings when in fact it is all smoke and mirrors as the constituent elements that would make alcohol enriched fuel better are too costly to add for a company that is just concerned with meeting minimum standards and making a profit.
Alcohol fuel has a lower enthalpy of heat then a regular premium fuel. What that means is per a certain volume it has less energy. To get the same amount of energy you need more of it.
The specific gravity of alcohol enriched fuel changes more with temperature. And living in a country like Canada where 70 degree temp changes during the course of a day are a regular occurrence for many months it is harder to tune an engine for consistent performance.
Alcohol enriched fuels may evaporate easier but they have a lower heat of vaporization, The higher a fuel’s heat of vaporization, the better its ability to cool the intake mixture which is a bonus for making power.
Alcohol enriched fuel burns slower, hence why some engines are good at pulling back timing to allow them to burn more completely. So many people think that is an indication that there engine is making more power but in reality it is only trying to burn the fuel that is yielding LESS power... The alcohol enriched fuels we get continue to burn past 20 deg ATDC (After Top Dead Center) which adds nothing to the overall power output of an engine.
The fact is these low alcohol fuels are missing the those expensive components to make them something other than some environmental propaganda.
Now this is just a very very basic over view of why I do not like alcohol enriched fuel, a person could write a book on the subject and still not do it justice.
That is the nature of alcohol fuels for many reasons but some of them are above. Just because you added timing does not make them better.
Alcohol enriched fuels are hog wash forced on us from states like California that have the people power to effect and entire continent.
I tried once before several days ago but I pressed send and the page disappeared.
Alcohol fuel is bad on different levels and so many.
It is dry fuel with poor lubrication properties, you may not think that is a big deal as your engine has oil in it but it is also a solvent that strips away that lubrication. So in the absence of oil and the fuel having poor lubrication properties that dries things out you have a recipe for accelerated engine wear; also store an engine running alcohol fuel for any time and you have potential for stuck valves, rings and such.
Alcohol fuels do not store well as they are hydrophilic; meaning they absorb water.
Alcohol is added for environmental reasons not because it makes a better fuel, Small amounts of alcohol in a fuel adds the appearance of better octane ratings when in fact it is all smoke and mirrors as the constituent elements that would make alcohol enriched fuel better are too costly to add for a company that is just concerned with meeting minimum standards and making a profit.
Alcohol fuel has a lower enthalpy of heat then a regular premium fuel. What that means is per a certain volume it has less energy. To get the same amount of energy you need more of it.
The specific gravity of alcohol enriched fuel changes more with temperature. And living in a country like Canada where 70 degree temp changes during the course of a day are a regular occurrence for many months it is harder to tune an engine for consistent performance.
Alcohol enriched fuels may evaporate easier but they have a lower heat of vaporization, The higher a fuel’s heat of vaporization, the better its ability to cool the intake mixture which is a bonus for making power.
Alcohol enriched fuel burns slower, hence why some engines are good at pulling back timing to allow them to burn more completely. So many people think that is an indication that there engine is making more power but in reality it is only trying to burn the fuel that is yielding LESS power... The alcohol enriched fuels we get continue to burn past 20 deg ATDC (After Top Dead Center) which adds nothing to the overall power output of an engine.
The fact is these low alcohol fuels are missing the those expensive components to make them something other than some environmental propaganda.
Now this is just a very very basic over view of why I do not like alcohol enriched fuel, a person could write a book on the subject and still not do it justice.
That is the nature of alcohol fuels for many reasons but some of them are above. Just because you added timing does not make them better.
Alcohol enriched fuels are hog wash forced on us from states like California that have the people power to effect and entire continent.
unless you have some REAL WORLD DATA not what you read in a book, online or your engineering school told you to prove otherwise you will never convince me of these ill effects.. we have 1500+Hp supras running ethanol all the way down to 450hp evos driving daily for almost 5 years on it.. We have tested back to back on numerous occasions the power we can safely pull out of cars on 93 with and without ethanol and its hands down safer with ethanol and it makes more power PERIOD..
Mike
#26
He did not quote what he read on the pump, Todd is a tuner that read his durametric log from his engine during a staged test with the two different fuels. The 91 no alcohol fuel was found to be a better performer due to as a result of looking at the engine parameters.
Absolutlely and completely wrong about alcohols heat of vaporization. and regular fuel. Now you can add chemicals to alcohol that change the properties to raise that number. Alcohol does not add more power because you can burn more, it does require more fuel to equal the same amount of thermal units per a certain volume of non alcohol enriched gas though.
I do not know about the chemistry of brazillian fuel but here in North America alcohol enriched fuels are legislated due to government policy; not performance or economic viability; and due to environmental reasons the fuel makers do not use certain chemicals that actually make alcohol enriched fuels a better performance product. Now I am not talking E85 which can be considered a cheap performance fuel; but that is no smoking gun either as a car needs some costly modifications to run the stuff.
Fuel chemistry is a subject that is debated by many an internet expert yet it is understood by so few (Heck I could be one of those un knowing ***** for all anyone here knows) but I can say for a fact that my money goes on good non alcohol enriched fuel. If I want the extra octane I mix race gas into the equation or even use Torco additive.
Sorry Edit.... As most here will not know this... The Torco fuel accelerator died with Torco going under but a product called Green Trail Accelerator is the same product.
Don't trust me ask everyones buddy Jay
http://www.jaylenosgarage.com/video/...-fuel/1288164/
Absolutlely and completely wrong about alcohols heat of vaporization. and regular fuel. Now you can add chemicals to alcohol that change the properties to raise that number. Alcohol does not add more power because you can burn more, it does require more fuel to equal the same amount of thermal units per a certain volume of non alcohol enriched gas though.
I do not know about the chemistry of brazillian fuel but here in North America alcohol enriched fuels are legislated due to government policy; not performance or economic viability; and due to environmental reasons the fuel makers do not use certain chemicals that actually make alcohol enriched fuels a better performance product. Now I am not talking E85 which can be considered a cheap performance fuel; but that is no smoking gun either as a car needs some costly modifications to run the stuff.
Fuel chemistry is a subject that is debated by many an internet expert yet it is understood by so few (Heck I could be one of those un knowing ***** for all anyone here knows) but I can say for a fact that my money goes on good non alcohol enriched fuel. If I want the extra octane I mix race gas into the equation or even use Torco additive.
Sorry Edit.... As most here will not know this... The Torco fuel accelerator died with Torco going under but a product called Green Trail Accelerator is the same product.
Don't trust me ask everyones buddy Jay
http://www.jaylenosgarage.com/video/...-fuel/1288164/
#27
You have a car that defies everything we have ever tested on 100s of cars.. Id check the car, the tune, or the fuel because something is DEAD WRONG in that equation my friend..
#28
I don't use ethanol blended gas on my Lambo tho...
unless I went TT one day.
#29
Well last year I didn't beleive markski either when he told me that Shell 91 was better than husky 94. He even sent me logs showing the ECU dumping fuel on the husky 94 trying to protect itself....
So I had to do some logs myself.....
hoesntly I wish the husky 94 was better, cause It's easy for me to get. Just as easy as shell 91. So I wouldn't mind gas that can make more power and be safer.....
#30
Great debate...I see only one post with data (bravo TTdude). Of course no one is considering the measurement error for the tests performed by the tuners. I do know that in CO we have had 10% ethanol (by law) for many years...and cars are still running. Since the higher octane fuels are harder to detonate (therefore less knock), I find it hard to believe the 91 will perform better than the 94 (provided your ECU is mapped to take advantage of this). I have also seen little data to suggest the "additives" actually increase octane by much if at all.