True cost of ownership.... reality check! ; )
#31
02-19-2008 | 03:44 PM
Thread Starter
|
Registered User
Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 1,750
From: Miami
Rep Power: 124
On a happy note and update.... they finished with my car, test drove it and the coils are bad. X-Warr is picking the tab for the coils and also the pullley fo the alternator. The X-warranty bill is close to $6K and I'm only paying $75 deduct! OMG!!!! I will end with a brand new car!!!! 
Also, they are talking to Porsche reps to see what can they do about my cats...
So far, between the X-warranty and the Pirela checkbook:
New Clutch (complete)
New RMS seal (Later edition with updated everything including the IMS screws, etc...)
New front suspension (minus shock absorbers) links, arms and sway bars
New starter
New alternator
New pulleys
New Oil and filter
New air filter
New cabin filter
New spark plugs
New coils
New sunroof switch
New actuator gas lid
replaced small coolant hose over left bank (leaking)
All on a 1.5 month ownership....
That translates to:
no money for:
Tires
painted center console
painted door pockets and pull handles
shiftknob and handbrake (daytrader can get all of them!!!!
)
turbo front bumper
quad pipe exhaust tips
but just knowing that the car is gonna be perfect: priceless.
-joel
Also, they are talking to Porsche reps to see what can they do about my cats...
So far, between the X-warranty and the Pirela checkbook:
New Clutch (complete)
New RMS seal (Later edition with updated everything including the IMS screws, etc...)
New front suspension (minus shock absorbers) links, arms and sway bars
New starter
New alternator
New pulleys
New Oil and filter
New air filter
New cabin filter
New spark plugs
New coils
New sunroof switch
New actuator gas lid
replaced small coolant hose over left bank (leaking)
All on a 1.5 month ownership....
That translates to:
no money for:
Tires
painted center console
painted door pockets and pull handles
shiftknob and handbrake (daytrader can get all of them!!!!
)turbo front bumper
quad pipe exhaust tips
but just knowing that the car is gonna be perfect: priceless.
-joel
#32
02-19-2008 | 04:06 PM
Registered User
Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 370
From: Long Island (New York)
Rep Power: 37
Joel, welcome aboard. I've heard it said that there's no such thing as a cheap used Porsche -- you either pay up front, or you pay over time for repairs. Either way, you pay!
Good luck and enjoy.
Good luck and enjoy.
#33
02-19-2008 | 05:05 PM
Registered User
Joined: Feb 2006
Posts: 602
From: Panama
Rep Power: 57
From my post a few months ago:
Here is what I have had to endure in the last 18 months for a 24K mile car when purchased (30K miles now). I knew that it was a tad on the rough side, but never in my dreams did I think it would need these many repairs. Please note that the labor prices are here in Panama for non dealer mechanics (yet Porsche factory trained people). The large number before the $ amount is my mileage in kilometers. Add to this a MAF sensor that is dead (±$300) and a failed key remote (±$200). Now you will understand why I want to get rid of this car.....
4/29/06 Air, oil, particle filters Alemautos $105.81
5/2/06 Oil change (Mobil 1 15-50), fuel filter changed Taller 930 39,096 $130.00
5/4/06 Bosch starter motor refurbished Vertex $289.97
5/4/06 Bosch spark plugs (6) Vertex $57.78
5/8/06 Sachs clutch kit Vertex $401.25
5/8/06 Poly Rib belt Vertex $31.03
5/9/06 Porsche caliper decals Xenonmods.com $12.00
5/14/06 1 qt. Mobil 1 15-50 Delta Calle 50 39,200 $6.75
5/17/06 Wiper blades MW 22" Auto Centro 39,263 $11.03
5/19/06 Center console hinge kit Alemautos $25.00
5/22/06 Falken Azenis RT-615 225/40/18 & 265/35/18 Discount Tire Direct $943.33
5/22/06 Front corner headlight washer cover (right) Alemautos $34.08
5/26/06 Johnson Films Executive 35 Pit Stop C. de Este 39,387 $110.00
5/27/06 Labor clutch & starter 39,397 $400.00
5/28/06 Stem valves and caps Respuestos Mundiales $8.40
5/31/06 Hood crest kit Assesales (Ebay) 39,505 $35.95
6/1/06 Tire balance & install, 4 wheel alignment Servicentro Densa 39,511 $144.90
6/1/06 Porsche pedal set 5th-Gear (Ebay) $94.01
6/20/06 Mintex Red Box & ATE rubber brake hoses Rennsport Systems $225.85
6/30/06 Hood crest installed GOB 39,871 $0.00
7/3/06 Halogen bulbs (2) Left side replaced Alemautos $26.59
7/4/06 High temp red paint Discovery Center $9.29
7/4/06 ATE Super Blue brake fluid (2L) Servicios Carlos $34.00
7/21/06 Porsche coolant top off and bleed by me Alemautos 40,115 $13.21
10/5/06 Diagnose and recharge AC (evaporator dead) Auto Cooler Service 42,100 $35.00
11/7/06 Bosch fuel pump Vertex $244.40
11/21/06 Muffler bypass pipes Servicentro Mon 42,662 $18.90
11/25/06 Fuel pump replacement labor 42,681 $90.00
12/2/06 Re set fuel gauge and check OBD Alemautos 42,931 $26.25
12/2/06 Coolant expansion tank and coolant Alemautos $220.29
12/2/06 Coolant expansion tank labor 42,936 $100.00
12/20/06 Coolant cap Alemautos 43,400 $14.55
12/30/06 Evaporator, console hinge install, labor for all 43,575 $650.00
4/11/07 Droplinks (fronts only) Alemautos $85.39
4/11/07 Droplinks labor Servicentro Densa 45,250 $31.50
4/11/07 Rear window seal trim Alemautos $38.85
4/26/07 Rear window seal labor $40.00
6/7/07 Wheel bolts (2 afer breaking safety ones) Alemautos 46,090 $14.07
6/7/07 Removed mufflers GOB $0.00
6/19/07 Re install of muffler bypass pipes Rapid Muffler 46,453 $31.50
9/10/07 Replace water pump & coolant Alemautos 48,200 $408.28
12/7/07 Replace horn (1) Taller 930 49,500 $40.00
1/10/08 Front Bilstein Sport Pelican Parts $463.00
1/23/08 Suspension shipping Miami - Panama Mi Repuesto.com $94.50
1/25/08 Labor to install suspension, anti squeal, micro filter Taller 930 49,719 $144.00
1/25/08 Mobil 1 15-50 (1) Alemautos 49,726 $10.52
It soon may go to another home, but something tells me the next owner will be luckier as there is not much left to do to it! I just need something a bit better for my back and kids (thinking BMW X5 4.6/4.8is). If you want to feel better about maintenance on Porsches, take a look over at the Cayenne forum!
Here is what I have had to endure in the last 18 months for a 24K mile car when purchased (30K miles now). I knew that it was a tad on the rough side, but never in my dreams did I think it would need these many repairs. Please note that the labor prices are here in Panama for non dealer mechanics (yet Porsche factory trained people). The large number before the $ amount is my mileage in kilometers. Add to this a MAF sensor that is dead (±$300) and a failed key remote (±$200). Now you will understand why I want to get rid of this car.....
4/29/06 Air, oil, particle filters Alemautos $105.81
5/2/06 Oil change (Mobil 1 15-50), fuel filter changed Taller 930 39,096 $130.00
5/4/06 Bosch starter motor refurbished Vertex $289.97
5/4/06 Bosch spark plugs (6) Vertex $57.78
5/8/06 Sachs clutch kit Vertex $401.25
5/8/06 Poly Rib belt Vertex $31.03
5/9/06 Porsche caliper decals Xenonmods.com $12.00
5/14/06 1 qt. Mobil 1 15-50 Delta Calle 50 39,200 $6.75
5/17/06 Wiper blades MW 22" Auto Centro 39,263 $11.03
5/19/06 Center console hinge kit Alemautos $25.00
5/22/06 Falken Azenis RT-615 225/40/18 & 265/35/18 Discount Tire Direct $943.33
5/22/06 Front corner headlight washer cover (right) Alemautos $34.08
5/26/06 Johnson Films Executive 35 Pit Stop C. de Este 39,387 $110.00
5/27/06 Labor clutch & starter 39,397 $400.00
5/28/06 Stem valves and caps Respuestos Mundiales $8.40
5/31/06 Hood crest kit Assesales (Ebay) 39,505 $35.95
6/1/06 Tire balance & install, 4 wheel alignment Servicentro Densa 39,511 $144.90
6/1/06 Porsche pedal set 5th-Gear (Ebay) $94.01
6/20/06 Mintex Red Box & ATE rubber brake hoses Rennsport Systems $225.85
6/30/06 Hood crest installed GOB 39,871 $0.00
7/3/06 Halogen bulbs (2) Left side replaced Alemautos $26.59
7/4/06 High temp red paint Discovery Center $9.29
7/4/06 ATE Super Blue brake fluid (2L) Servicios Carlos $34.00
7/21/06 Porsche coolant top off and bleed by me Alemautos 40,115 $13.21
10/5/06 Diagnose and recharge AC (evaporator dead) Auto Cooler Service 42,100 $35.00
11/7/06 Bosch fuel pump Vertex $244.40
11/21/06 Muffler bypass pipes Servicentro Mon 42,662 $18.90
11/25/06 Fuel pump replacement labor 42,681 $90.00
12/2/06 Re set fuel gauge and check OBD Alemautos 42,931 $26.25
12/2/06 Coolant expansion tank and coolant Alemautos $220.29
12/2/06 Coolant expansion tank labor 42,936 $100.00
12/20/06 Coolant cap Alemautos 43,400 $14.55
12/30/06 Evaporator, console hinge install, labor for all 43,575 $650.00
4/11/07 Droplinks (fronts only) Alemautos $85.39
4/11/07 Droplinks labor Servicentro Densa 45,250 $31.50
4/11/07 Rear window seal trim Alemautos $38.85
4/26/07 Rear window seal labor $40.00
6/7/07 Wheel bolts (2 afer breaking safety ones) Alemautos 46,090 $14.07
6/7/07 Removed mufflers GOB $0.00
6/19/07 Re install of muffler bypass pipes Rapid Muffler 46,453 $31.50
9/10/07 Replace water pump & coolant Alemautos 48,200 $408.28
12/7/07 Replace horn (1) Taller 930 49,500 $40.00
1/10/08 Front Bilstein Sport Pelican Parts $463.00
1/23/08 Suspension shipping Miami - Panama Mi Repuesto.com $94.50
1/25/08 Labor to install suspension, anti squeal, micro filter Taller 930 49,719 $144.00
1/25/08 Mobil 1 15-50 (1) Alemautos 49,726 $10.52
It soon may go to another home, but something tells me the next owner will be luckier as there is not much left to do to it! I just need something a bit better for my back and kids (thinking BMW X5 4.6/4.8is). If you want to feel better about maintenance on Porsches, take a look over at the Cayenne forum!
#35
02-19-2008 | 06:30 PM
Registered User
Joined: Apr 2006
Posts: 53
From: San Jose CA
Rep Power: 21
When I got my car, I also had an extended warranty (still has it until this coming July) and in the first 3 months the Ext-Warr covered for a cracked expansion tank, bad ignition switch, bad seat control module, and bad outside rear view mirror switch. With the labor cost included, that ext-warr almost paid off for itself. But since then, I have had no issues at all (knock on wood), great sport car, I love it... Good luck with yours.
#36
02-19-2008 | 07:28 PM
Registered User
Joined: Jun 2004
Posts: 176
From: LA
Rep Power: 29
I have a '99 C2 that I bought in 2004. Four years and 20k miles later (now at 50k), I've had to replace the clutch, RMS seal, the brakes, coolant tank, and multiple oil changes. I didn't have extended warranty so I had to foot the $3k bill for clutch/RMS/brakes.
It's a lot of money... but at the end of the day, you still have one great car. I think the best solution is to go out for a drive and it'll be all worth it.
It's a lot of money... but at the end of the day, you still have one great car. I think the best solution is to go out for a drive and it'll be all worth it.
#37
02-19-2008 | 07:39 PM
Registered User
Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 370
From: Long Island (New York)
Rep Power: 37
My 2001 911 has been the most trouble-free car I've ever owned. After 7 years of ownership, I haven't needed a single repair -- just routine maintenance.
Oh, BTW, I now have 5,200 miles.
Oh, BTW, I now have 5,200 miles.
#38
02-19-2008 | 07:48 PM
Registered User
Joined: Apr 2006
Posts: 53
From: San Jose CA
Rep Power: 21
#39
02-19-2008 | 09:56 PM
I've had my 996 since November, so I don't have much of a history yet; not with this Porsche. I drive it regularly and no leaks or issues yet. This thread is great b/c it gives me a glimpse into the future.
#40
02-20-2008 | 12:34 PM
Registered User
Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 370
From: Long Island (New York)
Rep Power: 37
NOT a typo. 5,200 miles to date. Good thing I bought the Porsche battery maintainer.
#41
02-20-2008 | 12:40 PM
Registered User
Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 812
From: Dallas
Rep Power: 52
if you want reliability i probably wouldn't get a BMW. more of the same, just different German guys building it.
From my post a few months ago:
Here is what I have had to endure in the last 18 months for a 24K mile car when purchased (30K miles now). I knew that it was a tad on the rough side, but never in my dreams did I think it would need these many repairs. Please note that the labor prices are here in Panama for non dealer mechanics (yet Porsche factory trained people). The large number before the $ amount is my mileage in kilometers. Add to this a MAF sensor that is dead (±$300) and a failed key remote (±$200). Now you will understand why I want to get rid of this car.....
4/29/06 Air, oil, particle filters Alemautos $105.81
5/2/06 Oil change (Mobil 1 15-50), fuel filter changed Taller 930 39,096 $130.00
5/4/06 Bosch starter motor refurbished Vertex $289.97
5/4/06 Bosch spark plugs (6) Vertex $57.78
5/8/06 Sachs clutch kit Vertex $401.25
5/8/06 Poly Rib belt Vertex $31.03
5/9/06 Porsche caliper decals Xenonmods.com $12.00
5/14/06 1 qt. Mobil 1 15-50 Delta Calle 50 39,200 $6.75
5/17/06 Wiper blades MW 22" Auto Centro 39,263 $11.03
5/19/06 Center console hinge kit Alemautos $25.00
5/22/06 Falken Azenis RT-615 225/40/18 & 265/35/18 Discount Tire Direct $943.33
5/22/06 Front corner headlight washer cover (right) Alemautos $34.08
5/26/06 Johnson Films Executive 35 Pit Stop C. de Este 39,387 $110.00
5/27/06 Labor clutch & starter 39,397 $400.00
5/28/06 Stem valves and caps Respuestos Mundiales $8.40
5/31/06 Hood crest kit Assesales (Ebay) 39,505 $35.95
6/1/06 Tire balance & install, 4 wheel alignment Servicentro Densa 39,511 $144.90
6/1/06 Porsche pedal set 5th-Gear (Ebay) $94.01
6/20/06 Mintex Red Box & ATE rubber brake hoses Rennsport Systems $225.85
6/30/06 Hood crest installed GOB 39,871 $0.00
7/3/06 Halogen bulbs (2) Left side replaced Alemautos $26.59
7/4/06 High temp red paint Discovery Center $9.29
7/4/06 ATE Super Blue brake fluid (2L) Servicios Carlos $34.00
7/21/06 Porsche coolant top off and bleed by me Alemautos 40,115 $13.21
10/5/06 Diagnose and recharge AC (evaporator dead) Auto Cooler Service 42,100 $35.00
11/7/06 Bosch fuel pump Vertex $244.40
11/21/06 Muffler bypass pipes Servicentro Mon 42,662 $18.90
11/25/06 Fuel pump replacement labor 42,681 $90.00
12/2/06 Re set fuel gauge and check OBD Alemautos 42,931 $26.25
12/2/06 Coolant expansion tank and coolant Alemautos $220.29
12/2/06 Coolant expansion tank labor 42,936 $100.00
12/20/06 Coolant cap Alemautos 43,400 $14.55
12/30/06 Evaporator, console hinge install, labor for all 43,575 $650.00
4/11/07 Droplinks (fronts only) Alemautos $85.39
4/11/07 Droplinks labor Servicentro Densa 45,250 $31.50
4/11/07 Rear window seal trim Alemautos $38.85
4/26/07 Rear window seal labor $40.00
6/7/07 Wheel bolts (2 afer breaking safety ones) Alemautos 46,090 $14.07
6/7/07 Removed mufflers GOB $0.00
6/19/07 Re install of muffler bypass pipes Rapid Muffler 46,453 $31.50
9/10/07 Replace water pump & coolant Alemautos 48,200 $408.28
12/7/07 Replace horn (1) Taller 930 49,500 $40.00
1/10/08 Front Bilstein Sport Pelican Parts $463.00
1/23/08 Suspension shipping Miami - Panama Mi Repuesto.com $94.50
1/25/08 Labor to install suspension, anti squeal, micro filter Taller 930 49,719 $144.00
1/25/08 Mobil 1 15-50 (1) Alemautos 49,726 $10.52
It soon may go to another home, but something tells me the next owner will be luckier as there is not much left to do to it! I just need something a bit better for my back and kids (thinking BMW X5 4.6/4.8is). If you want to feel better about maintenance on Porsches, take a look over at the Cayenne forum!
Here is what I have had to endure in the last 18 months for a 24K mile car when purchased (30K miles now). I knew that it was a tad on the rough side, but never in my dreams did I think it would need these many repairs. Please note that the labor prices are here in Panama for non dealer mechanics (yet Porsche factory trained people). The large number before the $ amount is my mileage in kilometers. Add to this a MAF sensor that is dead (±$300) and a failed key remote (±$200). Now you will understand why I want to get rid of this car.....
4/29/06 Air, oil, particle filters Alemautos $105.81
5/2/06 Oil change (Mobil 1 15-50), fuel filter changed Taller 930 39,096 $130.00
5/4/06 Bosch starter motor refurbished Vertex $289.97
5/4/06 Bosch spark plugs (6) Vertex $57.78
5/8/06 Sachs clutch kit Vertex $401.25
5/8/06 Poly Rib belt Vertex $31.03
5/9/06 Porsche caliper decals Xenonmods.com $12.00
5/14/06 1 qt. Mobil 1 15-50 Delta Calle 50 39,200 $6.75
5/17/06 Wiper blades MW 22" Auto Centro 39,263 $11.03
5/19/06 Center console hinge kit Alemautos $25.00
5/22/06 Falken Azenis RT-615 225/40/18 & 265/35/18 Discount Tire Direct $943.33
5/22/06 Front corner headlight washer cover (right) Alemautos $34.08
5/26/06 Johnson Films Executive 35 Pit Stop C. de Este 39,387 $110.00
5/27/06 Labor clutch & starter 39,397 $400.00
5/28/06 Stem valves and caps Respuestos Mundiales $8.40
5/31/06 Hood crest kit Assesales (Ebay) 39,505 $35.95
6/1/06 Tire balance & install, 4 wheel alignment Servicentro Densa 39,511 $144.90
6/1/06 Porsche pedal set 5th-Gear (Ebay) $94.01
6/20/06 Mintex Red Box & ATE rubber brake hoses Rennsport Systems $225.85
6/30/06 Hood crest installed GOB 39,871 $0.00
7/3/06 Halogen bulbs (2) Left side replaced Alemautos $26.59
7/4/06 High temp red paint Discovery Center $9.29
7/4/06 ATE Super Blue brake fluid (2L) Servicios Carlos $34.00
7/21/06 Porsche coolant top off and bleed by me Alemautos 40,115 $13.21
10/5/06 Diagnose and recharge AC (evaporator dead) Auto Cooler Service 42,100 $35.00
11/7/06 Bosch fuel pump Vertex $244.40
11/21/06 Muffler bypass pipes Servicentro Mon 42,662 $18.90
11/25/06 Fuel pump replacement labor 42,681 $90.00
12/2/06 Re set fuel gauge and check OBD Alemautos 42,931 $26.25
12/2/06 Coolant expansion tank and coolant Alemautos $220.29
12/2/06 Coolant expansion tank labor 42,936 $100.00
12/20/06 Coolant cap Alemautos 43,400 $14.55
12/30/06 Evaporator, console hinge install, labor for all 43,575 $650.00
4/11/07 Droplinks (fronts only) Alemautos $85.39
4/11/07 Droplinks labor Servicentro Densa 45,250 $31.50
4/11/07 Rear window seal trim Alemautos $38.85
4/26/07 Rear window seal labor $40.00
6/7/07 Wheel bolts (2 afer breaking safety ones) Alemautos 46,090 $14.07
6/7/07 Removed mufflers GOB $0.00
6/19/07 Re install of muffler bypass pipes Rapid Muffler 46,453 $31.50
9/10/07 Replace water pump & coolant Alemautos 48,200 $408.28
12/7/07 Replace horn (1) Taller 930 49,500 $40.00
1/10/08 Front Bilstein Sport Pelican Parts $463.00
1/23/08 Suspension shipping Miami - Panama Mi Repuesto.com $94.50
1/25/08 Labor to install suspension, anti squeal, micro filter Taller 930 49,719 $144.00
1/25/08 Mobil 1 15-50 (1) Alemautos 49,726 $10.52
It soon may go to another home, but something tells me the next owner will be luckier as there is not much left to do to it! I just need something a bit better for my back and kids (thinking BMW X5 4.6/4.8is). If you want to feel better about maintenance on Porsches, take a look over at the Cayenne forum!
#42
02-20-2008 | 01:04 PM
Thread Starter
|
Registered User
Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 1,750
From: Miami
Rep Power: 124
that's 742 miles a year.... A YEAR!!!! 
I put 500 miles a week!!!
I should get my car back soon.... to bad I'm in Japan right now!
joel pirela
#43
02-20-2008 | 02:01 PM
Registered User
Joined: Nov 2007
Posts: 251
From: Denver, CO
Rep Power: 36
repairs
I hate to say thsi Joel but your repair nightmares are, most likely, only beginning. The Porsches I have seen that are daily drivers are, at best, costly. You must have a decent sized check book if you want to drive a USD100,000 performance car as a daily driver.
I have also seen that Porsches that need repair...need ALOT! It seems to be one of those either extremes.
Ill probably get in trouble for saying this but here it goes....Porsches are NOT reliable quality built daily drivers. Its a performance car. Permormance cars break. No free lunch.
I would consider taking the car back and cutting your losses. Have you talked to an attorney? You may be able to take the car back (they may be obligated to do so) and get a better one (from someone else). I certainly would not keep it any longer.
I have also seen that Porsches that need repair...need ALOT! It seems to be one of those either extremes.
Ill probably get in trouble for saying this but here it goes....Porsches are NOT reliable quality built daily drivers. Its a performance car. Permormance cars break. No free lunch.
I would consider taking the car back and cutting your losses. Have you talked to an attorney? You may be able to take the car back (they may be obligated to do so) and get a better one (from someone else). I certainly would not keep it any longer.
#44
02-20-2008 | 02:08 PM
Registered User
Joined: Aug 2005
Posts: 2,521
From: Orlando
Rep Power: 120
Disagree COMPLETELY. I put 100,000 miles on my C4 Cab in 4 years...I paid for 2 repairs and the normal upkeep. I bought a CPO car and while under warranty alot of things got fixed for free. Once all those issues were ironed out, it was a VERY reliable car. Remember, its the first water cooled 911..EVER. So there will be issues. If you want ultimate reliability buy a Lexus...but other than that ALL upscale brands will have issues of some sort.
#45
02-20-2008 | 02:34 PM
Registered User
Joined: Nov 2007
Posts: 251
From: Denver, CO
Rep Power: 36
mediocre
^^^ Im with him I bought my car with 61K miles on it and since have over 103K now. daily driver/beater and no major problems. I had to replace one coil, window regulators, a coolant hose and my coolant resivoir cap. thats it! Oh and maybe a couple little oil leaks but very very reliable : )
Unbelieveable. "Oh and a couple of little oil leaks". I love how you brushed that aside. No offense but your car should not have a couple of oil leaks in 40k. Thats just bad.
Dont get me wrong. Porsches are cool. So are Harleys and they should come with a tool kit or a second job.
Go to NSXprime.com and noone is ever complianing that their car breaking and that they have oil leaks.