99 Carrera 4 with no 2nd gear
#17
No, they are not. The second gear synchro issue has been around for a while, and it doesn't take any serious abuse for the problem to rear it's ugly head. Look around enough and you can find all the threads. It is also not just a Turbo-only problem.
I talked to Erik at Carquip, about a year or year or two ago (they had a different name then, and I was Beachside996), but decided to get a remanufactured transmission instead. I ended up trading the car in on my S63 about 4 months ago, and they gave me more than enough over book on it as a trade-in to cover the difference IMO, so I don't regret having replaced it.
If funds are an issue for the OP, and he feels that the motor is okay (no IMS issues - RMS is not a big deal), then a rebuild by Carquip would be a reasonable thing to do, and he could put more money into the car in mods as time goes by. It's not a question of if, but when he mods his car, if he hangs out here any amount of time.
To the OP: I would absolutely not consider driving the car w/o 2nd gear. For you to get into the torque band of a 3.4, you are going to have to rev to redline in normal traffic in 1st gear for you to stay with the flow of traffic in 3rd gear. It would not be fun. Running the engine up to redline in the first three gears is certainly fun when you have the room to do it, but not running the engine to redline in 1st in normal traffic. If you really want the car, buy it, get the tranmission rebuilt, and then you can really enjoy it the way it was meant to be enjoyed.
I talked to Erik at Carquip, about a year or year or two ago (they had a different name then, and I was Beachside996), but decided to get a remanufactured transmission instead. I ended up trading the car in on my S63 about 4 months ago, and they gave me more than enough over book on it as a trade-in to cover the difference IMO, so I don't regret having replaced it.
If funds are an issue for the OP, and he feels that the motor is okay (no IMS issues - RMS is not a big deal), then a rebuild by Carquip would be a reasonable thing to do, and he could put more money into the car in mods as time goes by. It's not a question of if, but when he mods his car, if he hangs out here any amount of time.
To the OP: I would absolutely not consider driving the car w/o 2nd gear. For you to get into the torque band of a 3.4, you are going to have to rev to redline in normal traffic in 1st gear for you to stay with the flow of traffic in 3rd gear. It would not be fun. Running the engine up to redline in the first three gears is certainly fun when you have the room to do it, but not running the engine to redline in 1st in normal traffic. If you really want the car, buy it, get the tranmission rebuilt, and then you can really enjoy it the way it was meant to be enjoyed.
#19
But if you are experiencing the shifter "popping" out of second gear (You do a normal shift from 1st to 2nd, then the engine revs because it is in neutral, you depress the clutch and go for 2nd again, all while muttering "I know it was in second gear") after you absolutely know that you engaged that gear properly, it will only get worse. I really thought it was me at some point, and then I remembered that I have driven quite a few cars with manual transmissions that this never happened in. Sorry to be the bearer of bad news.
#20
It's really the synchros that are going, not the gear. Shift into second very carefully, and think of it like shifting into neutral first, then second gear instead of a straight shift from first to second. That is the best way I can explain it.
But if you are experiencing the shifter "popping" out of second gear (You do a normal shift from 1st to 2nd, then the engine revs because it is in neutral, you depress the clutch and go for 2nd again, all while muttering "I know it was in second gear") after you absolutely know that you engaged that gear properly, it will only get worse. I really thought it was me at some point, and then I remembered that I have driven quite a few cars with manual transmissions that this never happened in. Sorry to be the bearer of bad news.
But if you are experiencing the shifter "popping" out of second gear (You do a normal shift from 1st to 2nd, then the engine revs because it is in neutral, you depress the clutch and go for 2nd again, all while muttering "I know it was in second gear") after you absolutely know that you engaged that gear properly, it will only get worse. I really thought it was me at some point, and then I remembered that I have driven quite a few cars with manual transmissions that this never happened in. Sorry to be the bearer of bad news.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
proTUNING Freaks
997 Turbo / GT2
17
09-15-2015 07:28 AM
Wheel Experts
991
0
09-02-2015 09:04 AM
Wheel Experts
Wheels/Tires
0
09-02-2015 09:02 AM