997 TT beats GT-R at Ring. Nissan accused of cheating.
#1366
I'm not taking a "stab at the GTR Fanclub", and I haven't quoted from magazines. My point is that I can break any car if I choose to, if I treat it badly - Veyron, 997, GT-R, ZR1, whatever. Give me half an hour, and I'll give you back a broken car.
I wouldn't because I'm not an idiot. An idiot is someone who buys a new $80k 500 bhp AWD car and goes out and uses the launch control dozens of times, sometimes even before the manufacturer's break in period is complete, and then whines when something breaks.
I'm certainly not a "fanboy" either - I'm just questioning why there is so much bad feeling toward a car which in my experience is really very, very good.
There has been no negative advertising or comparisons by Nissan with competitors, just the observation that they benchmarked against a 997 Turbo in development. So why all the doubters? Why the comments when it loses a drag race against much more powerful, lighter cars? Why all the fuss when someone hears of a warranty issue? Seems strange to me.
I like cars, not brands.
I wouldn't because I'm not an idiot. An idiot is someone who buys a new $80k 500 bhp AWD car and goes out and uses the launch control dozens of times, sometimes even before the manufacturer's break in period is complete, and then whines when something breaks.
I'm certainly not a "fanboy" either - I'm just questioning why there is so much bad feeling toward a car which in my experience is really very, very good.
There has been no negative advertising or comparisons by Nissan with competitors, just the observation that they benchmarked against a 997 Turbo in development. So why all the doubters? Why the comments when it loses a drag race against much more powerful, lighter cars? Why all the fuss when someone hears of a warranty issue? Seems strange to me.
I like cars, not brands.
#1367
#1368
Another lull. Somebody say something, I need my fix for today!
#1369
I'll even say something out of character for myself: I don't think that the GTR is all that bad looking, it even looks kinda hot in black!
#1370
Last edited by bbywu; 11-04-2008 at 06:12 PM.
#1371
Yes, I believe that is a little too much carbon fiber in the wrong place.
#1372
I'll say something.
The balance/AWD on the GT-R seems better than 997TT in one real-world test. We got our first rain here in SF last week. When tooling up a local twisty road, there is a steep uphill switch-back that also feels a bit off camber (wants to throw you into other lane as you crest the middle of turn). Pretty dangerous to take >15-20MPH in the wet.
So anyway, I took it >25 MPH in the wet. In the TT, the back end rotates around and the PSM goes crazy. The AWD does help much for some reason-- I am guessing not enough weight on front to get power down and pull you around.
In the GT-R, you can be pretty aggressive with the throttle and you just get a little 4-wheel drift and the front wheels pull you around nicely. If VDC was working for me, I didn't notice. Certainly didn't complain about a little sliding.
I was't going for any crazy drift driving, just having fun.
GT-R is just so damn easy to drive.
HC may chime in and say a real man would learn to drive the 911 better in such conditions, even if it means going PSM-off and risking a trip to body shop. No thanks.
-Chris
The balance/AWD on the GT-R seems better than 997TT in one real-world test. We got our first rain here in SF last week. When tooling up a local twisty road, there is a steep uphill switch-back that also feels a bit off camber (wants to throw you into other lane as you crest the middle of turn). Pretty dangerous to take >15-20MPH in the wet.
So anyway, I took it >25 MPH in the wet. In the TT, the back end rotates around and the PSM goes crazy. The AWD does help much for some reason-- I am guessing not enough weight on front to get power down and pull you around.
In the GT-R, you can be pretty aggressive with the throttle and you just get a little 4-wheel drift and the front wheels pull you around nicely. If VDC was working for me, I didn't notice. Certainly didn't complain about a little sliding.
I was't going for any crazy drift driving, just having fun.
GT-R is just so damn easy to drive.
HC may chime in and say a real man would learn to drive the 911 better in such conditions, even if it means going PSM-off and risking a trip to body shop. No thanks.
-Chris
Last edited by chrisn; 11-04-2008 at 07:08 PM.
#1373
#1374
#1375
#1376
I'll say something.
The balance/AWD on the GT-R seems better than 997TT in one real-world test. We got our first rain here in SF last week. When tooling up a local twisty road, there is a steep uphill switch-back that also feels a bit off camber (wants to throw you into other lane as you crest the middle of turn). Pretty dangerous to take >15-20MPH in the wet.
So anyway, I took it >25 MPH in the wet. In the TT, the back end rotates around and the PSM goes crazy. The AWD does help much for some reason-- I am guessing not enough weight on front to get power down and pull you around.
In the GT-R, you can be pretty aggressive with the throttle and you just get a little 4-wheel drift and the front wheels pull you around nicely. If VDC was working for me, I didn't notice. Certainly didn't complain about a little sliding.
I was't going for any crazy drift driving, just having fun.
GT-R is just so damn easy to drive.
HC may chime in and say a real man would learn to drive the 911 better in such conditions, even if it means going PSM-off and risking a trip to body shop. No thanks.
-Chris
The balance/AWD on the GT-R seems better than 997TT in one real-world test. We got our first rain here in SF last week. When tooling up a local twisty road, there is a steep uphill switch-back that also feels a bit off camber (wants to throw you into other lane as you crest the middle of turn). Pretty dangerous to take >15-20MPH in the wet.
So anyway, I took it >25 MPH in the wet. In the TT, the back end rotates around and the PSM goes crazy. The AWD does help much for some reason-- I am guessing not enough weight on front to get power down and pull you around.
In the GT-R, you can be pretty aggressive with the throttle and you just get a little 4-wheel drift and the front wheels pull you around nicely. If VDC was working for me, I didn't notice. Certainly didn't complain about a little sliding.
I was't going for any crazy drift driving, just having fun.
GT-R is just so damn easy to drive.
HC may chime in and say a real man would learn to drive the 911 better in such conditions, even if it means going PSM-off and risking a trip to body shop. No thanks.
-Chris
Depends on how your car is setup, and if I'm not mistaken, you have MPSC on your car so, so likely your "balance" problems are more due to MPSC not being very good in the rain.
I'm also assuming these arent Porsche spec MPSC which are REALLY bad on wet roads especially when they havent been driven and cornered hard enogh prior to to get heat in them and soften them up.
Did you have MPSC on the TT? Not that it matters much since you have a 700 hp TT, which in the rain is going to blaze through any set of tires. But you certainly arent using the information wisely in presenting a balance statement.
FWIW, I dont turn PSM off on wet STREETS either, especially on MPSC, but I will on wet track.
#1377
Depends on how your car is setup, and if I'm not mistaken, you have MPSC on your car so, so likely your "balance" problems are more due to MPSC not being very good in the rain.
I'm also assuming these arent Porsche spec MPSC which are REALLY bad on wet roads especially when they havent been driven and cornered hard enogh prior to to get heat in them and soften them up.
Did you have MPSC on the TT? Not that it matters much since you have a 700 hp TT, which in the rain is going to blaze through any set of tires. But you certainly arent using the information wisely in presenting a balance statement.
FWIW, I dont turn PSM off on wet STREETS either, especially on MPSC, but I will on wet track.
I'm also assuming these arent Porsche spec MPSC which are REALLY bad on wet roads especially when they havent been driven and cornered hard enogh prior to to get heat in them and soften them up.
Did you have MPSC on the TT? Not that it matters much since you have a 700 hp TT, which in the rain is going to blaze through any set of tires. But you certainly arent using the information wisely in presenting a balance statement.
FWIW, I dont turn PSM off on wet STREETS either, especially on MPSC, but I will on wet track.
Also, not sure why 700HP matters. I am not flooring it.
At any rate, this thread is now moot. A few minutes ago some guys showed up at my house and towed away my TT and my GT-R. Said they were redistributing them to some "working class" families. When I protested that they can't just confiscate my hard earned private property, they just started chanting "Yes we can! Yes we can!" Bizarre.
#1378
Not sure why 700 hp matters when you can put down almost all the power in the GT-R and are on street tires?
Ok, man.
Ok, man.
#1379
That's politics for you. Maybe Joe the Plumber will get the GTR. Damn, someone just dropped a 997TT off in front of my house!!!
#1380
here is some very interesting info from a highly accomplished N-ring driver who tested the GTR himself. He has some info on the best GTR lap by Walter Rohrl and the "record setting" GTR.
Its funny how fast information goes around the world! I drove the Nissan GTR yesterday for KW with the KW clubsport and with the original suspension. All other parts were stock and the weight was original! Due to the fact, that there where some passing manouvers and 2 small mistakes in my line, the theoretical best time, calculated from my best sectors (with data logger), was a 7.46. ( a real lap was 7,49)
So I think, it is not possible, to go faster, when W.Röhrl and Chr.Menzel also where not able to go under 7.45!
The secret source, who watched the test of the 3 cars is not so secret: He owns a guest house in Nürbrug and was there at the test and watched everything. I spoke to him 2 days ago and it was true that tha car was far away from stock, that means power, sound, tyres, exhaust, weight!
But anyway the Nissan GTR is fast also in stock outfit and fun to drive. Only when acclerating it would need more power to the rear, to kill the understeer. Under braking conditions it steers very good into corners! Sometimes to much, but then it is even more fun!
If You want, You can post that in the internet! Source: Wolf!
Danke und Viele Grüße
So I think, it is not possible, to go faster, when W.Röhrl and Chr.Menzel also where not able to go under 7.45!
The secret source, who watched the test of the 3 cars is not so secret: He owns a guest house in Nürbrug and was there at the test and watched everything. I spoke to him 2 days ago and it was true that tha car was far away from stock, that means power, sound, tyres, exhaust, weight!
But anyway the Nissan GTR is fast also in stock outfit and fun to drive. Only when acclerating it would need more power to the rear, to kill the understeer. Under braking conditions it steers very good into corners! Sometimes to much, but then it is even more fun!
If You want, You can post that in the internet! Source: Wolf!
Danke und Viele Grüße