Which are the five lightest wheels for the 997 turbo?
#91
so of the available wheels
Tech 1
BBS FI
Champion Mag ?
or any others.
Can we get a listing of actual weights for the same size wheels and pics for comparison?
Since this is posted in the 997TT lets have each vendor (or interested individual) post a picture of two of the wheel that they feel best represents light and strong, and the actual weight for the 99TT fitment, and whether they are TPMS compatible.
Tech 1
BBS FI
Champion Mag ?
or any others.
Can we get a listing of actual weights for the same size wheels and pics for comparison?
Since this is posted in the 997TT lets have each vendor (or interested individual) post a picture of two of the wheel that they feel best represents light and strong, and the actual weight for the 99TT fitment, and whether they are TPMS compatible.
The Tech1-210 is 7.31 kg (front) and 8.68 Kg (rear). This is due to the straighter spokes in the concave design.
All of our monoblock wheels are 100% TPMS compatible.
#92
Are those your lightest wheels??
#93
Putting the quotes together:
Champion RS 98: 19x8.5 (8.2 kg), 19x11.5 (9.06 kg)
Dymags: front (7.62kg), rear (9.30kg) (Seem high?? They are actual measured weights by imcarnuts.)
Tech1-110: 19x8.5 (7.53Kg) , 19x11.5 (8.93 Kg)
BBS Fi: 19x8.75 (7.4 kg ), 19x12 (8.9 kg)
I haven't looked up the costs (lazy), but note that there are large differences between the wheels: Dymag 10k? >BBS Fi 7k?>Champion 5.5k?>Tech1 4k? (Please correct me as needed.).
Champion RS 98: 19x8.5 (8.2 kg), 19x11.5 (9.06 kg)
Dymags: front (7.62kg), rear (9.30kg) (Seem high?? They are actual measured weights by imcarnuts.)
Tech1-110: 19x8.5 (7.53Kg) , 19x11.5 (8.93 Kg)
BBS Fi: 19x8.75 (7.4 kg ), 19x12 (8.9 kg)
I haven't looked up the costs (lazy), but note that there are large differences between the wheels: Dymag 10k? >BBS Fi 7k?>Champion 5.5k?>Tech1 4k? (Please correct me as needed.).
Last edited by cannga; 04-15-2010 at 09:04 AM.
#96
Putting the quotes together:
Champion RS 98: 19x8.5 (8.2 kg), 19x11.5 (9.06 kg)
Dymags: front (7.62kg), rear (9.30kg) (Seem high?? They are actual measured weights by imcarnuts.)
Tech1-110: 19x8.5 (7.53Kg) , 19x11.5 (8.93 Kg)
BBS Fi: 19x8.75 (7.4 kg ), 19x12 (8.9 kg)
I haven't looked up the costs (lazy), but note that there are large differences between the wheels: Dymag 10k? >BBS Fi 7k?>Champion 5.5k?>Tech1 4k? (Please correct me as needed.).
Champion RS 98: 19x8.5 (8.2 kg), 19x11.5 (9.06 kg)
Dymags: front (7.62kg), rear (9.30kg) (Seem high?? They are actual measured weights by imcarnuts.)
Tech1-110: 19x8.5 (7.53Kg) , 19x11.5 (8.93 Kg)
BBS Fi: 19x8.75 (7.4 kg ), 19x12 (8.9 kg)
I haven't looked up the costs (lazy), but note that there are large differences between the wheels: Dymag 10k? >BBS Fi 7k?>Champion 5.5k?>Tech1 4k? (Please correct me as needed.).
Our Tech1-210 is a bit lighter than the Tech1-110 due to the straighter spokes.
Last I heard the HRE CF was no longer available due to their rim supplier going bust. Please correct me if i'm wrong.
Last edited by Tech1_Mike; 04-08-2010 at 06:02 PM.
#97
Putting the quotes together:
Champion RS 98: 19x8.5 (8.2 kg), 19x11.5 (9.06 kg)
Dymags: front (7.62kg), rear (9.30kg) (Seem high?? They are actual measured weights by imcarnuts.)
Tech1-110: 19x8.5 (7.53Kg) , 19x11.5 (8.93 Kg)
BBS Fi: 19x8.75 (7.4 kg ), 19x12 (8.9 kg)
I haven't looked up the costs (lazy), but note that there are large differences between the wheels: Dymag 10k? >BBS Fi 7k?>Champion 5.5k?>Tech1 4k? (Please correct me as needed.).
Champion RS 98: 19x8.5 (8.2 kg), 19x11.5 (9.06 kg)
Dymags: front (7.62kg), rear (9.30kg) (Seem high?? They are actual measured weights by imcarnuts.)
Tech1-110: 19x8.5 (7.53Kg) , 19x11.5 (8.93 Kg)
BBS Fi: 19x8.75 (7.4 kg ), 19x12 (8.9 kg)
I haven't looked up the costs (lazy), but note that there are large differences between the wheels: Dymag 10k? >BBS Fi 7k?>Champion 5.5k?>Tech1 4k? (Please correct me as needed.).
#98
The P40 has become an iconic wheel in the Porsche community.
But times change.
Now there are fresh styles, low weights, centerlocks, etc.
But as I've said countless times, competition is a wonderful thing. It keeps us sharp and it keeps things moving.
#99
Here's some irony for you. I'm a big fan of the P40. I was part of the team at HRE back in '06/'07 that developed and launched the HRE Monoblok program.
The P40 has become an iconic wheel in the Porsche community.
But times change.
Now there are fresh styles, low weights, centerlocks, etc.
But as I've said countless times, competition is a wonderful thing. It keeps us sharp and it keeps things moving.
The P40 has become an iconic wheel in the Porsche community.
But times change.
Now there are fresh styles, low weights, centerlocks, etc.
But as I've said countless times, competition is a wonderful thing. It keeps us sharp and it keeps things moving.
I followed the P40 even when it was called the M40 (M for Mercedes?). Yes, "iconic" is the word -- not because I have it either. Dymag and P40 remain 2 of the most beautiful wheels ever designed.
And yes competition is good. Knowing HRE -- I am certain they are not standing still. Alan might even be reading this for all I know!
I still would like to ask you some more questions about a comment you made earlier if you don't mind.
#100
Cannga, I'm going to go out on a limb here and state unequivocally that forged monoblock wheels are superior to any other commercially available wheel. They are clearly stronger, supporting more load for unit of wheel mass. It is our experience that our best engineered forged monoblocks are approximately 1 kg lighter than our best 3-piece design, in similar size and load rating. Also, the wheels can be made truer with less runout, consistently, than any 3-piece wheel. The monoblocks are actually less expensive to make on a unit cost basis, but require millions of dollars in powerful equipment to manufacture.
.......So, lighter, stronger, truer, less expensive and more trouble-free: thats my case.
In fairness, 3-piece wheels are easier to repair, and they can also incorporate complex finishes easier than a monoblock.
And for the record, the two lightest wheel designs available are monoblocks, made by BBS and Tech1.
.......So, lighter, stronger, truer, less expensive and more trouble-free: thats my case.
In fairness, 3-piece wheels are easier to repair, and they can also incorporate complex finishes easier than a monoblock.
And for the record, the two lightest wheel designs available are monoblocks, made by BBS and Tech1.
From what I could tell from the enclosed picture and in real life, they look like multi-piece BBS aluminum (or is it magnesium) wheel, no? (Please correct me as needed.)
Last edited by cannga; 04-09-2010 at 09:49 AM.
#101
Mike (or anyone), one more question: If these are these advantages, why do race cars use multi-piece wheel please?
From what I could tell from the enclosed picture and in real life, they look like multi-piece BBS aluminum (or is it magnesium) wheel, no? (Please correct me as needed.)
From what I could tell from the enclosed picture and in real life, they look like multi-piece BBS aluminum (or is it magnesium) wheel, no? (Please correct me as needed.)
Conversely, monoblock wheels are usually purpose-built and weight optimized for a single application. Changing the offset of a properly weight optimized monoblock wheel is not just a matter of milling the backpad. Often, it requires reshaping the curvature of the face. That in turn could require a different forging, different spin tooling, a different lathe program, or all three. And a 19x8.5 for a Porsche is a very different wheel than a 19x8.5 for an S-Class Mercedes. Face profile, rim thickness, etc are all different. Not so with most 3-piece programs.
Race cars are highly variable so having a 3-piece program that allows you to make 10 Teams' wheels, all from a small variety of components, is WAAAAAY cheaper than monoblocks.
#102
From an engineering perspective, there is nothing inherently unstable about lightweight wheels. Absolutely nothing.
However, if the wheels are not machined to very tight tolerances with very low runout (<0.3mm, .012 in), then the wheels can develop unpleasant harmonic vibration at high speed. This can be manifested by moderate to severe steering wheel shake. It is quite unnerving at high speed.
Multi-piece wheels like the Dymag are very difficult to manufacture with such high levels of concentricity. The more the pieces, the more difficult it is.
Not impossible, mind you, just difficult.
Forged monoblock wheels can be built with practically zero runout if one builds the proper tooling and fixtures. Not cheap, but very smooth at high speed.
However, if the wheels are not machined to very tight tolerances with very low runout (<0.3mm, .012 in), then the wheels can develop unpleasant harmonic vibration at high speed. This can be manifested by moderate to severe steering wheel shake. It is quite unnerving at high speed.
Multi-piece wheels like the Dymag are very difficult to manufacture with such high levels of concentricity. The more the pieces, the more difficult it is.
Not impossible, mind you, just difficult.
Forged monoblock wheels can be built with practically zero runout if one builds the proper tooling and fixtures. Not cheap, but very smooth at high speed.
Back to the issue: twice now I've seen bad runout mentioned as a possible cause to wheel instability.
1. Just curious: Is this radial and lateral runout that you (& Champion) are talking about? If radial, I assume this kind of problem won't be taken care of adequately during installation by rotating tire on rim and make the overall runout even?
2. Are you saying bad runout is more of a problem with multi-piece wheel, versus monoblock wheel? And...
3. More specifically, only the *forged* (not cast) monoblock wheel has minimum runout? Thanks again.
Last edited by cannga; 04-11-2010 at 09:22 AM.
#103
tech1 group buy?
The Tech1s are $4795 list for 19s and $4995 list for 20s. But we currently have a group buy going for April
Our Tech1-210 is a bit lighter than the Tech1-110 due to the straighter spokes.
Last I heard the HRE CF was no longer available due to their rim supplier going bust. Please correct me if i'm wrong.
Our Tech1-210 is a bit lighter than the Tech1-110 due to the straighter spokes.
Last I heard the HRE CF was no longer available due to their rim supplier going bust. Please correct me if i'm wrong.
I thought there was an issue with supply atm?
#104
Hi Mike, one more question and I will be done with you. Ok maybe be 2, or 3. (I very much appreciate the professional expertise.)
Back to the issue: twice now I've seen bad runout mentioned as a possible cause to wheel instability.
1. Just curious: Is this radial and lateral runout that you (& Champion) are talking about? If radial, I assume this kind of problem won't be taken care of adequately during installation by rotating tire on rim and make the overall runout even?
2. Are you saying bad runout is more of a problem with multi-piece wheel, versus monoblock wheel? And...
3. More specifically, only the *forged* (not cast) monoblock wheel has minimum runout? Thanks again.
Back to the issue: twice now I've seen bad runout mentioned as a possible cause to wheel instability.
1. Just curious: Is this radial and lateral runout that you (& Champion) are talking about? If radial, I assume this kind of problem won't be taken care of adequately during installation by rotating tire on rim and make the overall runout even?
2. Are you saying bad runout is more of a problem with multi-piece wheel, versus monoblock wheel? And...
3. More specifically, only the *forged* (not cast) monoblock wheel has minimum runout? Thanks again.
2. Multi-piece wheels require precision alignment during assembly. The individual components each have runout and so the tolerances can "stack". You could look through a batch of components and pick the ones that best offset the deficiencies in the other components. Very laborious and I have never seen this in practice at any wheel company. What generally happens is the assembly runout standards are just lower. A common standard for multi-piece wheels is .025 in (0.6mm). Most quality monoblock wheels use 0.3mm as the standard and this is required by all of our European tuner customers. The difference doesn't sound like much, but it requires precision fixtures and machining. It also creates a very smooth high-speed driving experience.
3. Any monoblock wheel that is made with great care can achieve the tolerances described. The OEMs use lots of cast wheels that are 0.3mm true.
The material is not the issue, only the workmanship and quality systems.
Love the questions....ask all you want. Forewarned is forearmed.