The dreaded evidence of over rev spikes on the 1 to 6 range counters.
#46
Wow! I still see those types of things... In fact I had a phone call yesterday from a person with a GT3 that had blown his engine.... He bought a flash and was told that they could put it to stock before he went to the Dealer. Well they tried and the CVN was still bad so no warranty since he had a tuned file in one way or another....
Then again you can only fix so much.
Then again you can only fix so much.
Last edited by Softronic; 07-26-2011 at 01:22 PM.
#47
Yes that is correct when done properly.
Just as a heads up the lack of over revs in a PIWIS tester or having none would show as a line -. When they do occur they would be listed as the number with the hours of occurrence such as Range 1 120/232H etc. , none would read Range 1 -.
Over revs can also be erased or added with the proper knowledge just as programming operations and IPAS data pulled from DME's. The pulling of the IPAS data and resetting the programming operations is mainly done for Dealers. This is when they entered the wrong data while trying to program a car and do not know what they entered, such as a Imob code. The resetting would be if the DME had been programmed 3 times by the dealer and then required a 4th to a factory file. They would normally in the past not use the DME and have to use another starting at 0.
Just as a heads up the lack of over revs in a PIWIS tester or having none would show as a line -. When they do occur they would be listed as the number with the hours of occurrence such as Range 1 120/232H etc. , none would read Range 1 -.
Over revs can also be erased or added with the proper knowledge just as programming operations and IPAS data pulled from DME's. The pulling of the IPAS data and resetting the programming operations is mainly done for Dealers. This is when they entered the wrong data while trying to program a car and do not know what they entered, such as a Imob code. The resetting would be if the DME had been programmed 3 times by the dealer and then required a 4th to a factory file. They would normally in the past not use the DME and have to use another starting at 0.
Porsche has infinite tools that most people are not aware of, even tuners. With your dealership experience as a former Porsche tech Scott, you should know this.
Misleading people into thinking software can mask anything in the ECU is just wrong, I'm sorry. When anyone asks me straight up, "will GIAC software void my warranty"....the answer is always "YES". Of course, our Champion warranty backs you up anyway, but that's another thread
Wow! I still see those types of things... In fact I had a phone call yesterday from a person with a GT3 that had blown his engine.... He bought a flash and was told that they could put it to stock before he went to the Dealer. Well they tried and the CVN was still bad so no warranty since he had a tuned file in one way or another....
Then again you can only fix so much.
Then again you can only fix so much.
That little jab was unnecessary. We can all point fingers at tunes that have blown motors...and being at a dealership I can probably point more fingers then most of you...but I won't and don't. Let's keep it classy
Last edited by Tom@Champion; 07-26-2011 at 02:28 PM.
#48
Our software for 996 and 997 models does not report overrevs in the range that we raise the rev limit (IE if we raise the rev limiter to 7200, it will not report in range 1 or 2). We also have the ability to correct it for customers who switch to our software. We leave the actual overrevs above redline "live" for diagnostic purposes.
I should add that before late 2009, we would just raise the rev limit for people who had to have it (with fair warning). At that time, we realized that no one could properly do this. So we spent the engineering hours to figure out how to modify the thresholds and the values properly. Not being reliant on third parties to make flashing and map writing tools really works to our benefit in cases like this. Our engineering team has the ability to understand the program flow in the DME and see which values and tables it uses, and when. We have a large number of OE Porsche dealers who scan our vehicles flashed with our software regularly and report no odd findings.
Last edited by Andrew@GIAC; 07-26-2011 at 02:08 PM.
#49
You can turn the counter completely off with software but you can't adjust the ranges. If you turn it completely off it will absolutely be a red flag because some cars right off the boat even have range 1's! The only way to completely erase all memory of the over-revs is to reprogram the ECU.
Porsche has infinite tools that most people are not aware of, even tuners. With your dealership experience as a former Porsche tech Scott, you should know this.
Misleading people into thinking software can mask anything in the ECU is just wrong, I'm sorry. When anyone asks me straight up, "will GIAC software void my warranty"....the answer is always "YES". Of course, our Champion warranty backs you up anyway, but that's another thread
Just a slight correction. Porsche DID agree to replace Martin's engine.
That little jab was unnecessary. We can all point fingers at tunes that have blown motors...and being at a dealership I can probably point more fingers then most of you...but I won't and don't. Let's keep it classy
Porsche has infinite tools that most people are not aware of, even tuners. With your dealership experience as a former Porsche tech Scott, you should know this.
Misleading people into thinking software can mask anything in the ECU is just wrong, I'm sorry. When anyone asks me straight up, "will GIAC software void my warranty"....the answer is always "YES". Of course, our Champion warranty backs you up anyway, but that's another thread
Just a slight correction. Porsche DID agree to replace Martin's engine.
That little jab was unnecessary. We can all point fingers at tunes that have blown motors...and being at a dealership I can probably point more fingers then most of you...but I won't and don't. Let's keep it classy
Now as far as Martin??? I do not know what or who you are talking about, it looks like the jab was the other way.
I didn't say anything about masking yet you did???
#50
Come on man...you know exactly what we're talking about. Let's not go down this road. He and I are friends.
#51
Bravo. That right there is a refreshing thing to hear. Money obviously isn't everything and keeping it honest is always the right way.
#52
My previous post was simply speaking of over rev reporting and that alone.
#55
Masking would be trying to cover up a tune that is in the car and would never pass a Bin pull.
I simply pull the entire binary to check the race cars for this reason.
#56
You could set it below that, 7150, 7100, 7000 etc.
#57
You can turn the counter completely off with software but you can't adjust the ranges. If you turn it completely off it will absolutely be a red flag because some cars right off the boat even have range 1's! The only way to completely erase all memory of the over-revs is to reprogram the ECU.
What is easier is to change any of them to whatever you want. Yes they can be altered to any number or hour. This is not something that I do as part of any flash though.
Now if a car had over revs in 1 off the boat it wouldn't be a given that whom ever buys it would would continue to get more , correct? Many people never rev their car to the red line so no more over revs would ever be increased. Many never put any on the cars its entire life.
#58
Firstly i would like to thank the tuners Scott (Softronic), Austin (Giac), Tom (CMS) Alex (Sharkwerks) and to the various others making a valued contribution to this thread. Its an honour to have you guys chime in the way you all have to clear this topic up once and for all. Thanks . Now on to the topic at hand...
[quote]
Thank you for your advice Tom.
Scott as an example how would you interpret a range 5 (7900 to 9000)that reads 3/123h? or, a range 6 (9000 to 11000) that reads 1/123h?
Note these examples are also 3 ignitions or less so if the code had a deviation to 4 ignitions then neither range would show as a spike?
Also what is the maths to work out eg: a range 1 with 456/321h? How many times does that mean its hit into that range?
For Scott:
1) Scott, is Skandalis correct in saying that the piwis tool is truly the only real way of making an accurate determination of the ranges that have been hit?
2) Have you ever had any experience of inaccuracy in this area using Durametric 6?
[quote]
We're fortunate enough to be in the position of being a tuner, but also obviously affiliated with a dealer.
Here's the thing about having a tuned ECU and over-revs. Even if you're redline is raised....over-revs are STILL recorded at the factory levels. If you're rev limiter is set to 7300 then you'll record a range 3 over-rev every time you go there. If anyone tells you otherwise they're simply lying. quote]
Here's the thing about having a tuned ECU and over-revs. Even if you're redline is raised....over-revs are STILL recorded at the factory levels. If you're rev limiter is set to 7300 then you'll record a range 3 over-rev every time you go there. If anyone tells you otherwise they're simply lying. quote]
Note these examples are also 3 ignitions or less so if the code had a deviation to 4 ignitions then neither range would show as a spike?
Also what is the maths to work out eg: a range 1 with 456/321h? How many times does that mean its hit into that range?
TTdude...I ve seen several dyrametric readouts that wont make sense...PIWIS is the right tool to have the proper icon of your overrevs/engine hours...However try to download latest version of dyrametric and read the revs again...
Scott...based on your post,assuming we have a manual 997TT and i ask you to raise rev limit to 9000rpm,if i change before 9000rpm and not hit rev limiter,i wont see overrevs?is that the case?
Scott...based on your post,assuming we have a manual 997TT and i ask you to raise rev limit to 9000rpm,if i change before 9000rpm and not hit rev limiter,i wont see overrevs?is that the case?
1) Scott, is Skandalis correct in saying that the piwis tool is truly the only real way of making an accurate determination of the ranges that have been hit?
2) Have you ever had any experience of inaccuracy in this area using Durametric 6?
Last edited by speed21; 07-28-2011 at 05:59 AM.
#59
Here's sort of a chart that might help..lol:
Range:
1 -- Don't stress it, the dealer won't.
2 -- Don't stress it, the dealer still won't....but come on, shift when the needle gets close to the red!
3 -- OK...you need to start paying closer attention to those upshifts. The dealer might give you a slap on the wrist, but nothing to worry about.
4 -- Probably need to work on downshifting a little. Not a warranty-breaker, but might raise a few eyebrows at the dealer depending on the circumstances.
5,6 -- Something is wrong. Maybe your shifter linkage is messed up, or maybe someone told you 5th --> 2nd was OK...but you're flirting with disaster. Eventually, something WILL break.
The last 2 cars that came in here with blown motors each showed Range 5 and 6 over-revs. At that level, you're seriously testing the mechanical limitations of the engine. Eventually, it will cause a problem. Some people don't get more then one chance....it could be that one Range 5 or 6 that breaks it.
Range:
1 -- Don't stress it, the dealer won't.
2 -- Don't stress it, the dealer still won't....but come on, shift when the needle gets close to the red!
3 -- OK...you need to start paying closer attention to those upshifts. The dealer might give you a slap on the wrist, but nothing to worry about.
4 -- Probably need to work on downshifting a little. Not a warranty-breaker, but might raise a few eyebrows at the dealer depending on the circumstances.
5,6 -- Something is wrong. Maybe your shifter linkage is messed up, or maybe someone told you 5th --> 2nd was OK...but you're flirting with disaster. Eventually, something WILL break.
The last 2 cars that came in here with blown motors each showed Range 5 and 6 over-revs. At that level, you're seriously testing the mechanical limitations of the engine. Eventually, it will cause a problem. Some people don't get more then one chance....it could be that one Range 5 or 6 that breaks it.
A similar discussion in the 997 section ended with far too much drama .