Do I need to move to a GT3?
#16
I love(d) my '05 997S, you know that- shoot, I shared hundreds of posts here about that. With the SC it was wicked.
But after a few DE's that went south for one mechanical failure or another (non-SC related), I am fed up. I need/ want something I can rely on to drive daily AND take to the track. Something with a more adaptable suspension.
I have lost some faith in the Carrera/ Carrera S to be that car. As it has become an increasingly better daily drive I fear it may have lost some of it's track competence.
The GT3 is built for the track, and can run at redline for hours on end, but I am not sure it's livable as a DD.
Am I nuts here, or is there something to this?
CATTMAN
But after a few DE's that went south for one mechanical failure or another (non-SC related), I am fed up. I need/ want something I can rely on to drive daily AND take to the track. Something with a more adaptable suspension.
I have lost some faith in the Carrera/ Carrera S to be that car. As it has become an increasingly better daily drive I fear it may have lost some of it's track competence.
The GT3 is built for the track, and can run at redline for hours on end, but I am not sure it's livable as a DD.
Am I nuts here, or is there something to this?
CATTMAN
obviously track only dedicated car on a trailer is where all people end up, if it dies you just tow it back and sort if out later. using DD as track car or driving 'half track' build-up car like mine to track and back is, well, risky. I just got issue at last DE - got car repaired today - coil on cylinder 2 died, i thought it was MAF sensor but it was not. So there is no easy answer.
As of what car to choose to make a track rat out of it, especially if you are not going to do club racing and do not care of classification rules - I cannot tell. spec miata, spec boxster, e36 based track M3 car, gt3 car, cup car - you choose.
Any 997 street car can be fitted with gt3 suspension. my car has it, it handles very similar to gt3 car. body is less rigid but other than that - it handled exceptionally well. gt3 motor will give more power but question is - if you are not racing - what do you need this power for?
as of motors - if you think gt3 engines do not die or are issues free - you are pretty much mistaken. they just cost much more to repair and more difficult to prove if it was a non-track related damage. I woud say - define your budget first, define how much you can set aside monthly/annually for repairs and look for car that fits into this budget, or you may be frustrated.
And to add a final note - if $11K or so for used M96/M97 motor is too much for anyones budget - I would think twice about getting this 997 car to a track. every time you get there it can die, it is as simple as that. if this financial hit is too much - choose a cheaper car to run. all crs die. M3 cars die, porsches die, miatas die as well, even more and i saw plenty of it so far, almost at each event i attended. so I do not have much illusions about longivity or life expectations on a track car, still, i like it too much to stop doing it.
new gt3 motor will be in $45K area. 997 tranny is 3K, gt3 tranny is $20K+. Do all that math first. And spit in the eye to whomever who says that cars on a track do not die.
Last edited by utkinpol; 07-05-2011 at 11:55 AM.
#19
very cheap, a lot of fun, great field to run with and very easy to start racing it. i very much may end up there too as repairing 997 is, well, expensive. but costs to buy tow vehicle, trailer, storage, etc. infrastructure for spec car also costs money and, well, requires some serious family negotiations.
#20
OK, I may begin to look for a GT3.
I may be the first out there to retro-fit a rear shoulder belt in one, but that should be easily done as the anchor points are there. It's for my son's car seat, also likely a first in a GT3. If I go this route, I'll of course keep you updated with pics.
For now, my focus remains on figuring out what to do with my limping 997SC.
CATTMAN
I may be the first out there to retro-fit a rear shoulder belt in one, but that should be easily done as the anchor points are there. It's for my son's car seat, also likely a first in a GT3. If I go this route, I'll of course keep you updated with pics.
For now, my focus remains on figuring out what to do with my limping 997SC.
CATTMAN
#21
hmm. from what I know 997 gt3 does not have welded anchor points no more for rear seatbelts. they were there in 996 gt3 only. but i may be wrong.
gt3 as a DD car is an odd idea. low rpms torque will be less than on GTS car.
gt3 as a DD car is an odd idea. low rpms torque will be less than on GTS car.
#22
Cattman it seems you might think the GT3 engine is more reliable than a Carrera engine. I don't believe for street/de use this is the case. As for a DD car personally I could drive a GT3 everyday...that is having fun in life to me...do it while your young enough I say.
What did you ever fi d out as to why your super charged engine blew up?
What did you ever fi d out as to why your super charged engine blew up?
#23
Same here. I was considering if I should I mod my 997.1 C2, or get a 997.2 C2S, or a 2007 GT3.
I ditched the first option after finding that the mods would cost almost as much as the upgrade to .2.
Then I got to drive the GT3 for a few hours. I dont think I could live with this car as a DD, it really is RAW, + it just seems out of place in many situations. And that clutch in traffic... hmm... What's more I'm pretty sure I could not finance the cost of racing the car on a regular basis. No way.
So my final decision is to get a 997 C2S PDK + a cheap racing car that I can beat to death at small events.
My current little Carrera Tiptronic is already a blast to drive daily and is more than enough for me on the track (2-3 times a year) so the upgraed to 997.2 is all I need.
BTW I just came home after the first (rainy) event in my little old BMW 3 series racer and it was just as much fun as tracking my 997. I also found out what a crappy driver I am and how much I still have to learn... In the Porsche everything is so perfectly set up that even problems with driving technique are not so apparent.
Check this http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature...&v=66rOXrdCAto
I ditched the first option after finding that the mods would cost almost as much as the upgrade to .2.
Then I got to drive the GT3 for a few hours. I dont think I could live with this car as a DD, it really is RAW, + it just seems out of place in many situations. And that clutch in traffic... hmm... What's more I'm pretty sure I could not finance the cost of racing the car on a regular basis. No way.
So my final decision is to get a 997 C2S PDK + a cheap racing car that I can beat to death at small events.
My current little Carrera Tiptronic is already a blast to drive daily and is more than enough for me on the track (2-3 times a year) so the upgraed to 997.2 is all I need.
BTW I just came home after the first (rainy) event in my little old BMW 3 series racer and it was just as much fun as tracking my 997. I also found out what a crappy driver I am and how much I still have to learn... In the Porsche everything is so perfectly set up that even problems with driving technique are not so apparent.
Check this http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature...&v=66rOXrdCAto
#25
limp?
OK, I may begin to look for a GT3.
I may be the first out there to retro-fit a rear shoulder belt in one, but that should be easily done as the anchor points are there. It's for my son's car seat, also likely a first in a GT3. If I go this route, I'll of course keep you updated with pics.
For now, my focus remains on figuring out what to do with my limping 997SC.
CATTMAN
I may be the first out there to retro-fit a rear shoulder belt in one, but that should be easily done as the anchor points are there. It's for my son's car seat, also likely a first in a GT3. If I go this route, I'll of course keep you updated with pics.
For now, my focus remains on figuring out what to do with my limping 997SC.
CATTMAN
what's the limp and or problem? maybe someone here can help...
#26
#28
The new 991 is bigger, and most likely heavier then then the 997, so my money is on a 997.1GT3.
#29
I vote for buying a dedicated track car. And a DD. If space is a problem, buy an enclosed trailer and keep the track car in it, off site if necessary. This is absolutely the smart way to go, trust me. There are 100 reasons for this
#30
but, well, buying into used beaten up gt3 car (and good luck finding one that wasn`t tracked) - imho gt3 car with expired warranty can bite you very hard, it will need quite serious financial reserves in case if anything happens. imho if one if crazy enough to get dedicated track only gt3 car then it may be worth it jump directly into 996 cup car, motor is better than in any gt3, gearbox is less demanding than 997 cup sequential and it seems it may cost not that much more than to support 997.1 gt3.
Last edited by utkinpol; 07-06-2011 at 07:43 AM.