$61k is fair deal IMO, and even that could be swayed one way or the other depending on condition of normal wear parts (tires/brakes) and servicing/records.

 

I hear you on that...09 C4S well equipped and under 30k miles can be had for low 70s, so depending on where the price goes in the 60s for the 09 C2 you want, it could be worth your while to go a little extra for the AWD and S

 

So the offer is at $61k. Mine to take if I want it. Last question. Kbb says its worth 69k and edmunds say 59k. Quite the big difference. Do u think $61 is a good deal to jump on? Guess I want a objective view without my emotional decision making!

 

20k miles might be ok or it might as well be 60k depending on how it's been driven. At 20k miles you might being replacing brakes if driven hard. Also, is it on its first set of tires?

 

well according to the car fax, only things that stand out are 4/2009: registered. 11/2009: Maintenance inspection completed
Four tires mounted and balanced
Shift lever/assembly replaced . 5/2011: Tire(s) replaced. 9/2011: Four tires mounted and balanced.3/2012: Pre-delivery inspection completed
Nitrogen fill tires
Washed/detailed.