c7 stingray vs 997
#16
I had a Nissan 180 back in the early '90s that had one. Not sure why this fell off the map. I think it should be standard (with ability to turn on/off with a memory setting (so there is no default on/off behavior that must be modified each time you turn the car on)).
#18
I was very interested, still am a little, however every time I enter the Corvette Forums it confirms my belief Corvette owners have a well deserved reputation that I want no part of. Not saying all P-Car owners are perfect, but that place honestly reminds me of a Honda Civic forum sometimes.
This should not influence the car you buy, but I have been down this road before and for me it does. I had a 20th Anniversary GTI, I loved it, but the ricer attention it drew drove me nuts.
Very nice car for the money, I hope it pushes Porsche to either improve or realize they are way over-priced at this point.
This should not influence the car you buy, but I have been down this road before and for me it does. I had a 20th Anniversary GTI, I loved it, but the ricer attention it drew drove me nuts.
Very nice car for the money, I hope it pushes Porsche to either improve or realize they are way over-priced at this point.
#19
I was very interested, still am a little, however every time I enter the Corvette Forums it confirms my belief Corvette owners have a well deserved reputation that I want no part of. Not saying all P-Car owners are perfect, but that place honestly reminds me of a Honda Civic forum sometimes.
#20
The immaturity to me is beyond any forum I have ever been a part of and I have been an active member of dozens. Dare I say it is even worse than the 370z forum. Based on pictures of new owners GM failed to attract a younger crowd, most are 55-60 plus, how so many in this age bracket can be so immature is astonishing. There is also an extreme lack of basic intelligence.
To be clear it is not all members, but more than I have seen on any other forum.
Last edited by Carnut12; 03-02-2014 at 06:54 PM.
#21
Not ricey so my reference of Civic may be poor.
The immaturity to me is beyond any forum I have ever been a part of and I have been an active member of dozens. Dare I say it is even worse than the 370z forum. Based on pictures of new owners GM failed to attract a younger crowd, most are 55-60 plus, how so many in this age bracket can be so immature is astonishing. There is also am extreme lack of basic intelligence.
To be clear it is not all members, but more than I have seen on any other forum.
The immaturity to me is beyond any forum I have ever been a part of and I have been an active member of dozens. Dare I say it is even worse than the 370z forum. Based on pictures of new owners GM failed to attract a younger crowd, most are 55-60 plus, how so many in this age bracket can be so immature is astonishing. There is also am extreme lack of basic intelligence.
To be clear it is not all members, but more than I have seen on any other forum.
#23
I am on both Forums as well as Ferrarichat and there are always going to people who seem to loose their manners when they start typing. I am a one of those old guys (at least by my birth date) and I am way past letting any of that kind of stuff bother me or influence what car I drive. I write novels as a hobby and when you deal with critics you need a thick skin.
#24
This is an interesting topic. As MrPrice stated, I am at a point in my life where the opinion of other people will not affect my choices in the car(s) I drive, except for my wife to some degree. I was "thinking" about a C7. When I told her, she said the car was ugly and she asked me if I was having a mid-life crisis. I told her, "Unless I live to 110, I am past having a mid-life crisis and that she is the only woman I want in my sports car." That mollified her. She has no problem with the Cayman S I have on order. (Of course, she doesn't know how much they cost, nor will I tell her. I will cross that bridge when I have to.)
As for her comment on the C7, I certainly don't agree. I happen to like the C7 - except for the rear end. I would like to drive one, as they seem to be at least a match for Porsche performance when it comes to measurable Criteria. On the other hand, I would never give up my C4S for a C7. There is an intangible effect when I drive the car. It makes me smile - and that is what counts in the end.
As for her comment on the C7, I certainly don't agree. I happen to like the C7 - except for the rear end. I would like to drive one, as they seem to be at least a match for Porsche performance when it comes to measurable Criteria. On the other hand, I would never give up my C4S for a C7. There is an intangible effect when I drive the car. It makes me smile - and that is what counts in the end.
#25
I have an '87 Carrera 3.2, and a 2005 Carrera 997S, and a month ago I received my 2014 Stingray. I've got pretty much the same thread going on this debate right here: https://www.6speedonline.com/forums/...-stingray.html with over 8 pages of content already posted, so it would be great if these could be combined.
That said, fantastic review of the C7, and for the most part I agree that the 997S is more the car for me.
Here's why:
-the 997S seems to intuitively know what I want it to do at exactly the moment I want to do it, and is always, without fail, right there with me.
-the C7 forums are an absolute joke. There are some people who post well-thought-out comments, but the vast majority seem to be old, angry, rude, people, who have no life. Just my opinion, but as a 6Speed member for ages, hitting the C7 forums was a wake up call.
But I can tell you that this C7 (with Z51) kicks *** over my modified 997S, in a straight line, around a track, in the ****pit, with technology, on the stereo, etc. And everyone loves it. It's new, so still rare, but everywhere I go, I get thumbs up. Never knew how much love there was for the 'Vette, and always felt "special" in my 997S, but the Stingray is a whole other level of love, from all demographic segments.
I love the Stingray, but my 997S fits me like a glove. They are the SAME length! They weigh the same, and while the Stingray out-handles the 997S, the 997S feels better- to me. What can I say. Number are on the side of the 'Vette, but my emotions are with the 997S, even with mine being nearly 10 yrs old with 77k miles.
Here's a pic. I do think it screams "look at me!", but so does a lambo. It gets the attention because it really looks dramatic.
CATTMAN
That said, fantastic review of the C7, and for the most part I agree that the 997S is more the car for me.
Here's why:
-the 997S seems to intuitively know what I want it to do at exactly the moment I want to do it, and is always, without fail, right there with me.
-the C7 forums are an absolute joke. There are some people who post well-thought-out comments, but the vast majority seem to be old, angry, rude, people, who have no life. Just my opinion, but as a 6Speed member for ages, hitting the C7 forums was a wake up call.
But I can tell you that this C7 (with Z51) kicks *** over my modified 997S, in a straight line, around a track, in the ****pit, with technology, on the stereo, etc. And everyone loves it. It's new, so still rare, but everywhere I go, I get thumbs up. Never knew how much love there was for the 'Vette, and always felt "special" in my 997S, but the Stingray is a whole other level of love, from all demographic segments.
I love the Stingray, but my 997S fits me like a glove. They are the SAME length! They weigh the same, and while the Stingray out-handles the 997S, the 997S feels better- to me. What can I say. Number are on the side of the 'Vette, but my emotions are with the 997S, even with mine being nearly 10 yrs old with 77k miles.
Here's a pic. I do think it screams "look at me!", but so does a lambo. It gets the attention because it really looks dramatic.
CATTMAN
Last edited by Cattman; 03-03-2014 at 08:13 PM.
#26
I have an '87 Carrera 3.2, and a 2005 Carrera 997S, and a month ago I received my 2014 Stingray. I've got pretty much the same thread going on this debate right here: https://www.6speedonline.com/forums/...-stingray.html with over 8 pages of content already posted, so it would be great if these could be combined.
That said, fantastic review of the C7, and for the most part I agree that the 997S is more the car for me.
Here's why:
-the 997S seems to intuitively know what I want it to do at exactly the moment I want to do it, and is always, without fail, right there with me.
-the C7 forums are an absolute joke. There are some people who post well-thought-out comments, but the vast majority seem to be old, angry, rude, people, who have no life. Just my opinion, but as a 6Speed member for ages, hitting the C7 forums was a wake up call.
But I can tell you that this C7 (with Z51) kicks *** over my modified 997S, in a straight line, around a track, in the ****pit, with technology, on the stereo, etc. And everyone loves it. It's new, so still rare, but everywhere I go, I get thumbs up. Never knew how much love there was for the 'Vette, and always felt "special" in my 997S, but the Stingray is a whole other level of love, from all demographic segments.
I love the Stingray, but my 997S fits me like a glove. They are the SAME length! They weigh the same, and while the Stingray out-handles the 997S, the 997S feels better- to me. What can I say. Number are on the side of the 'Vette, but my emotions are with the 997S, even with mine being nearly 10 yrs old with 77k miles.
Here's a pic. I do think it screams "look at me!", but so does a lambo. It gets the attention because it really looks dramatic.
CATTMAN
That said, fantastic review of the C7, and for the most part I agree that the 997S is more the car for me.
Here's why:
-the 997S seems to intuitively know what I want it to do at exactly the moment I want to do it, and is always, without fail, right there with me.
-the C7 forums are an absolute joke. There are some people who post well-thought-out comments, but the vast majority seem to be old, angry, rude, people, who have no life. Just my opinion, but as a 6Speed member for ages, hitting the C7 forums was a wake up call.
But I can tell you that this C7 (with Z51) kicks *** over my modified 997S, in a straight line, around a track, in the ****pit, with technology, on the stereo, etc. And everyone loves it. It's new, so still rare, but everywhere I go, I get thumbs up. Never knew how much love there was for the 'Vette, and always felt "special" in my 997S, but the Stingray is a whole other level of love, from all demographic segments.
I love the Stingray, but my 997S fits me like a glove. They are the SAME length! They weigh the same, and while the Stingray out-handles the 997S, the 997S feels better- to me. What can I say. Number are on the side of the 'Vette, but my emotions are with the 997S, even with mine being nearly 10 yrs old with 77k miles.
Here's a pic. I do think it screams "look at me!", but so does a lambo. It gets the attention because it really looks dramatic.
CATTMAN
Speculation - you're used to driving the 911. I believe you know how to 'communicate' with it better, simply because your ownership has a longer tenure. Some things come natural.
#27
CATTMAN
#28
Did the event today. The car is fun, no doubt. Really easy to get the tail lose and super predicable once it is. The sport seats were excellent, manual transmission produced clean, crisp rifle bolt shifts (even a heel toe downshift to first on the autocross course was no problem). The auto was near dismal... mine felt like it kept cutting out the throttle during long pauses between shifts on the big track.
The steering was numb, and the handling, while great, also felt a little disconnected. The road was too dampened out from the ride. Even in track mode I missed the stiffer ride of the 997 in sport. Super fast in a straight line, but it felt like the back end stepped out too easily, which is fun, but the car could be faster if it didn't happen so much. Not sure what the skid pad is on the stingray, but it didn't feel better than the 997... Even if it is.
All in all a fun car, but it felt like it was just the big 6.2 liter engine that made it. Kind of a one trick pony. Also the engine when you look at hp per liter is awful. I think the V6 Camry might be better.
Still I get why these are so popular, but I'll take the 911 over this any day of the week. Unless of course you're taking about a pure hoonmobile... Then the C7 has the Porsche beat.
The steering was numb, and the handling, while great, also felt a little disconnected. The road was too dampened out from the ride. Even in track mode I missed the stiffer ride of the 997 in sport. Super fast in a straight line, but it felt like the back end stepped out too easily, which is fun, but the car could be faster if it didn't happen so much. Not sure what the skid pad is on the stingray, but it didn't feel better than the 997... Even if it is.
All in all a fun car, but it felt like it was just the big 6.2 liter engine that made it. Kind of a one trick pony. Also the engine when you look at hp per liter is awful. I think the V6 Camry might be better.
Still I get why these are so popular, but I'll take the 911 over this any day of the week. Unless of course you're taking about a pure hoonmobile... Then the C7 has the Porsche beat.
I attended the event back in October, 2013 and came away impressed enough to order a manual C7 with the needed options. I have a 2012 Carrera GTS Cab, manual as well and similarly equipped, and I enjoy it dearly. My reasoning was that the Stingray and the GTS are different enough that there was room for both in my garage. I never expected that the Stingray would take the place of the GTS, and I still don't. However, the level of enjoyment and general goodness of it continues to grow the more I use it. Forget the price, it is just plain fun to drive and very, very capable, and very, very comfortable at any price. It is a car that I look forward to driving regardless of where I'm going. I still don't expect it to take the place of the GTS, and I do wonder when/if the bloom is going to come off the rose. So far it hasn't and the attraction has only grown. All this from a real Porsche guy, admittedly one that doesn't take it to the track, but one who is also objective.
As for the "wow" factor, in the time I've owned it I've gotten more compliments and "wows" than I have gotten for all the different brand new 911's that I've owned. People have actually pulled alongside on two lane roads to snap cell phone pictures. That's not the kind of attention I'm necessarily looking for, but it is impressive.
And finally, this is maybe going to sound strange, but after having said all that, I look forward to my time with the GTS more now than ever before. The Corvette helps me to take note of the little refinements of the GTS that I may have forgotten or taken for granted. The Stingray has brought some conflict into my otherwise orderly life.
Ray
#29
I presently have a 2011 911 4S. I enjoy the car very much but will probable purchase a Corvette C7 as my next car. I can purchase a C7 with the Z51 package, magnetic ride, navagation, etc for about $61,000. Half the price of a new 911 S. Porsche has priced me out as a future customer.
#30
I presently have a 2011 911 4S. I enjoy the car very much but will probable purchase a Corvette C7 as my next car. I can purchase a C7 with the Z51 package, magnetic ride, navagation, etc for about $61,000. Half the price of a new 911 S. Porsche has priced me out as a future customer.
Ray