Fabspeed 997 GT3 High Performance Air Intake
#18
Originally Posted by K2@Brandywine
But where does the cold air come from after you take away the fans used for the dyno runs??? There is ALOT of heat in the rear of these cars.
#21
Let's see, replace the factory air intake system that a team of very highly paid engineers spent months designing using the latest CAD and computer airflow modelling programs (under various temperature and weather conditions) along with countless hours of wind tunnel testing WITH the factory wing in place (which the airbox is designed to work with) with....
....a big 'ol rectangular filter that just sits there? I wonder what these engineers are thinking when they see a product like this?
How was the dyno testing done? I'm guessing that you had a number of large fans blowing cold air directly over the engine bay during the runs - this hardly replicates real world driving. Also, you mentioned that multiple runs on the dyno were done. Does the published chart represent the "best" result? What about the worse? What was the standard deviation? I hate to sound like a skeptic, but I took several years of fluid dynamics in college, and I can only begin to imagine how much engineering goes into making something as "simple" as a factory airbox. I'm not saying all aftermarket intakes are bad - for example, I've seen the engineering that AEM does when designing a new intake system application. I just think that there's a huge difference in ENGINEERING vs. FABRICATION (which many tuners use interchangeably).
....a big 'ol rectangular filter that just sits there? I wonder what these engineers are thinking when they see a product like this?
How was the dyno testing done? I'm guessing that you had a number of large fans blowing cold air directly over the engine bay during the runs - this hardly replicates real world driving. Also, you mentioned that multiple runs on the dyno were done. Does the published chart represent the "best" result? What about the worse? What was the standard deviation? I hate to sound like a skeptic, but I took several years of fluid dynamics in college, and I can only begin to imagine how much engineering goes into making something as "simple" as a factory airbox. I'm not saying all aftermarket intakes are bad - for example, I've seen the engineering that AEM does when designing a new intake system application. I just think that there's a huge difference in ENGINEERING vs. FABRICATION (which many tuners use interchangeably).
Last edited by AlgaeHater; 08-18-2007 at 09:54 AM.
#23
Factory engineers have to design around laws (noise, etc.). I do believe it is possible for HP gains by indi aftermarket designers, but having said that it is no secret that "cold air" makes HP and not hot air!
Also there is a certain amount of "ram air" effect due to the scopes and sealed nature of the stock system and it looks like that aspect would be lost on your system as well.
How well will it perform in rain? Can it possibly get wet due to no cover?
Also there is a certain amount of "ram air" effect due to the scopes and sealed nature of the stock system and it looks like that aspect would be lost on your system as well.
How well will it perform in rain? Can it possibly get wet due to no cover?
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
PelicanParts.com
997 Vendor Classifieds
0
08-20-2015 02:39 PM
PelicanParts.com
GT3/GT2/GT Vendor Classifieds
0
08-20-2015 02:37 PM
ECS Tuning - VW
VW Vendor Classifieds
1
08-19-2015 11:08 AM