GT3 by far!

 

For track, I'd go with the NSX. It's a fundamentally better setup car, and has much more potential.

For street, I'd go with the GT3.

 

This is a Porsche forum. Car "x" versus GT3 polls are quite biased don't you think?
Personal choice is a good thing.

 

 

You have an viable argument to prove me wrong?

P.S. White Z06

 

Sure, Go drive a stock NSX and a stock 996 or 997 GT3 on a road course and report back.

 

That wasn't the question:

 

as a guy who has owned a couple p-cars, and a couple nsx's...they are very different, and neither is "better".....just different.

to say one is better is silly.

i do like the nsx more though

and damn luis, you know your biased

 

I got this list off the internet, here are some Nurburgring lap time. I know this is a HP track but don't assume NSX will out run the current track king "GT3"! I am a Honda Blue guy and know the NSX like it was the back of my palm! LOL. Look! The Integra Type R with 200HP out ran Corvette C5, E55 AMG and CLK43 AMG!

this is an old list but there's plenty of times there.

6:59 --- Ferrari 312T, Niki Lauda, German GP, training (1975)
7:06 --- Ferrari 312T, Clay Regazzoni, German GP, race (1975)
*1.2m longer circuit than standard Nordschleife

6:11 --- Porsche 956, Group C, Stefan Bellof, training (1983)
6:26 --- Porsche 956, Group C, Stefan Bellof, race (1983)
6:41 --- Porsche 956, Group C, Derek Bell
7:50 --- BMW X5 Le Mans V12, Hans Stuck (2001)
*0.232 km longer than current, standard Nordschleife

7:06 --- BMW M3 GTR, 24hrs, test session, JA¶rg MA1ller (2003)
7:19 --- Radical SR3 Turbo H22A (2003)
7:20* -- Opel Astra DTM V8 Coupe, set-up for 24hrs race (sport auto 2003) *estimated
7:25 --- Alzen Motorsport Porsche 996, 24hrs race, Uwe Alzen
7:28 --- Porsche Carrera GT, Walther RA¶hrl, Autobild July 2004
7:32.5 - Gemballa Porsche GTR 600 EVO, Wolfgang Kaufmann (2001)
7:36 --- Porsche Carrera GT, factory test driver Walther RA¶hrl (2002)
7:40* -- Porsche Carrera GT, *estimated time on cold and partially wet track (2003)
7:40 --- Mercedes Benz McLaren SLR, Klaus Ludwig, Autobild July 2004
7:42 --- Radical 1500 SR3 (2002)
7:43 --- TechArt GT Street (2001)
7:43 --- Porsche 996 911 GT3 RS
7:43.5 - Lamborghini Murcielago (Autocar magazine, 2002)
7:44 --- Pagani Zonda C12 S (2003)
7:45 --- Gemballa Porsche GT-R 600 (2000)
7:46 --- Porsche 996 GT2
7:46 --- SHK Porsche 993 GT2, 652 PS (1999)
7:47 --- Porsche 996 GT3 RS, 381PS (996) (2004)
7:49 --- Porsche 996 GT3 Cup
7:50 --- BMW E46 M3 CSL (08/2003)
7:50 --- Blitz Supra, 750 PS, Herbert SchA1rg (1997)
7:50 --- Honda RC30, Helmut Daehne (1993)
7:50 --- Lamborghini Murcielago (06/2002)
7:52 --- Gemballa Porsche 911 Le Mans (1995)
7:52 --- Lamborghini Gallardo E-Gear (12/2003)
7:52 --- Mercedes-Benz SLR McLaren (06/2004)
7:54 --- Porsche GT3 (996) (2003)
7:55 --- Caterham R500 Superlight (2002)
7:56 --- Ferrari 360 Challenge Stradale (02/2004)
7:56 --- Porsche 996 Turbo
7:56 --- Chevrolet Corvette C6 (tested by Dave Hill)
7:57 --- Lotec Porsche 993 Turbo, 600 PS, racing suspension
7:59 --- Porsche 911 Carrera S (997) (Performance Chassis) (Walter Rohrl - WHEELS June 2004)
8:02 --- Porsche 911 Carrera S (997) (Sport PASM setting) (Walter Rohrl - WHEELS June 2004)
8:03 --- Porsche 996 GT3 (1999)
8:04 --- Lamborghini Diablo GT (07/2000)
8:05 --- Ferrari 575M Maranello F1 (12/2002)
8:05 --- Porsche 911 Carrera S (997) (Normal PASM setting)(Walter Rohrl - WHEELS June 2004)
8:06 --- Mercedes-Benz SL55 AMG
8:06 --- Caterham 7 Superlight R, Robert Nearn
8:07 --- Ferrari 550 Maranello (06/1998)
8:09 --- Honda NSX-R 3.2 (08/2002)
8:09 --- Ferrari 360 Modena (10/1999)
8:09 --- Lamborghini Diablo SV (no ABS?)
8:10 --- Chrysler Viper GTS, 411PS, UK-Spec, no ABS (10/1997)
8:10 --- Donkervoort D8 180R
8:12 --- Mercedes-Benz SL55 AMG (04/2002)
8:12 --- Porsche 993 Turbo
8:13 --- Lotus Esprit Sport 350, 354 PS (05/1999)
8:15 --- Ruf 911 CTR 2, 520 PS
8:15*-- Holden GTS (2000), *estimated
8:15 --- Porsche 911 Carrera 2 (997) (Walter Rohrl - WHEELS June 2004)
8:16 --- AC-Schnitzer E36 M3 CLS II, 350 PS (11/1997)
8:17 --- Aston Martin V12 Vanquish (2003)
8:17 --- Porsche 996 C2
8:18 --- BMW Z8, 400 PS (08/2000)
8:18 --- Chevrolet Corvette Z06 Commemorative Edition, 344 PS (09/2003)
8:18 --- Ferrari F355 (06/1997)
8:20 --- Audi RS6 (2002)
8:22 --- BMW E46 M3 (12/2000)
8:22 --- BMW M Coupe, 321 PS (10/1998)
8:22 --- Mercedes-Benz C55 (07/2004)
8:23 --- Aston Martin DB7 GT (2003)
8:23 --- Porsche 996 Carrera 4
8:24 --- Subaru Impreza WRX STi (2004)
8:25 --- Audi RS4 375 HP
8:25 --- Callaway Corvette C12
8:25 --- Mitsubishi Carisma GT Evo VI (11/1999)
8:25 --- Mitsubishi Carisma GT Evo VII (11/2002)
8:26 --- Mercedes-Benz SLK 32 AMG (05/2001)
8:26 --- Nissan 350Z (2003)
8:28 --- BMW M5, 400 PS(also confirmed by Motor Commodore magazine, 2000)
8:28 --- Nissan Skyline GT-R, 277 PS
8:28 --- Porsche 993 Carrera 2
8:29 --- Mercedes-Benz CLK 55 AMG (05/2000)
8:29 --- Audi S4 4.2 Avant (11/2003)
8:30 --- Maserati CoupA© Cambiocorsa (10/2002)
8:31 --- Ferrari F355 GTS, 380 PS
8:32 --- BMW M Roadster, 321 PS (09/1997)
8:32 --- BMW Z4 3.0 SMG (05/2003)
8:32 --- Porsche Boxster S
8:32 --- Volkswagen Golf R32
8:34 --- Acura NSX, 276 PS
8:34 --- BMW Z3 CoupA© 3.0i, 231 PS (04/2001)
8:35 --- BMW M3 Coupe, 321 PS
8:35 --- Brabus-Mercedes Benz C V8 SportcoupA© (02/2002)
8:36 --- BMW E36 M3 EVO, 321 PS
8:36 --- Alpina-BMW B3 3.3 CoupA© (07/1999)
8:37 --- Maserati 3200GT (2002)
8:37 --- Mercedes-Benz C32 AMG (09/2001)
8:37 --- Nissan Skyline GT-R V-Spec, 350 PS
8:37 --- Subaru Impreza GT Turbo
8:37 --- Honda NSX 3.0 (07/1991)
8:38 --- Honda NSX 3.2 (08/1997)
8:38 --- Mercedes-Benz SL500 (12/2001)
8:38 --- Porsche 996 Carrera, 296 PS
8:38 --- Brabus-Mercedes Benz CLK 5.8 (12/1998)
8:39 --- Honda S2000 (01/2000)
8:39 --- Morgan Aero 8 (04/2003)
8:40 --- Holden GTS, on an in and out lap (2000)
8:40 --- Chevrolet Corvette C5 Targa Automatic (07/1997)
8:41 --- Aston Martin DB7 (1999)
8:41 --- Audi S3, 210 PS (06/1999)
8:42 --- Audi S4, 265 PS (08/1998)
8:42 --- Lotus Exige (11/2000)
8:43 --- Honda Integra Type-R (12/2000)
8:44 --- Chevrolet Corvette C5
8:45 --- Chevrolet Corvette, 339 PS, automatic
8:46 --- Porsche 993 Carrera S, 285 PS
8:47 --- Honda Civic Type-R, 200 PS (11/2001)
8:49 --- Jaguar XKR Coupe (07/1998)
8:49 --- Renault Clio Sport V6
8:49 --- Audi TT 1.8T quattro CoupA©, 225 PS (11/1998)
8:50* -- Mercedes Benz E55 AMG (2000)
8:51 --- Mercedes Benz C43 AMG (02/1998)
8:52 --- Mercedes Benz CLK 430
8:58 --- Lotus Esprit Turbo SE (07/1991)
9:09 --- Volkswagen Golf V6 4Motion

 

+1 I have a Supercharged NSX and other owners feel its what the NSX should have come with. A stock NSX is a fast car in its own world. Handling alone makes up for allot. Its true light weight rims, exshust, coilovers and you have a rocket of a car with the NSX for allot less $$$$. I have a rear Eng, 911 and on the track its a hand full but fun I get to drive others Porsches all the time 996TT C4s A CGT 930 each is just differant, and a good driver can make any car handle better by changing your lines and braking. I would love a GT3 as well but I will not sell my NSX to get one. Both great cars.

 

Interesting comparos. Reading and watching the NSX-R run its pace makes it seem like such an under-appreciated car. The GT-3 seems to be the only other car that would give such an exhilarating experience, but with the engine in the rear it's kind of a turn-off. Maybe that's part of the Porsche experience; don't know. I've been behind the wheel of one, but never around turns unfortunately. I would however love to hear track stories of both cars, particularly the NSX. Can anyone here who's had been behind both cars chime in?

 

Considering the fastest Time Attack NSX can't come close to the pace of IMSA GT3 Cup cars, I'd say you're very wrong. 1:31 vs. 1:28 at Laguna Seca. Even Speed GT on non-slicks became quicker than that.

Modding an older car vs. a stock new car, it's usually best to go with a new car. Especially a proven, globally raced car like the 911. Not to mention the factory and aftermarket support behind it.

The NSX will also need a brake upgrade. It would be Frankenstein's monster trying to get it to run as quick as a GT3. And the tuning headaches...

A well driven stock 996 GT3 on DOT rubber will turn sub 1:40s at Laguna. The NSX won't even be close.

It was a great car, the Porsche is just way beyond it.

 

I agree 100%. But how many Pcars do you see on the road, and even more so at the track vs the NSX ???

A stock NSX has nothing to be desired because it's a 20yo car. A stock Gt3 is far superior.

Honda left the NSX out to die in favor of uglier cars. Honda has even pulled completely out of F1 racing. Without factory support, Honda has already committed to killing the NSX.

But if the question was which is more fun to drive, then the answer is very subjective.A licensed SCCA driver will do sub 1:30 at Laguna in a spec Miata. So lap times will varies on driver's skill level.

Last time I checked, Honda's S2000 won the super street time attack @ buttonwillows, and before that NSX #77. I have much respect for the Gt3, but it's funny how most of them are giving me the point-bye on track days.

 

Spec Miata, which I believe are at 200hp, race prepped on slicks, run in the low 1:40s at Laguna. No Miata ever turned a sub 1:30 at Laguna.

S2000s were demoted to T3 but promoted in Autocross. Now imagine what you could do if you swapped with those that are giving you the point-bye?

Gates311: How is the NSX better set-up? Porsche competes just fine against mid-engine cars. And potential how?

 

If you'd like to compare a Shop built T/A car to a Factory built race car, then you're right. If you'd like to compare Factory built vs. Factory built....look to a JGTC NSX...

Fundamentally better setup car: Lighter, lower, mid engine, weight dist, lower Cd, etc....granted it's way down on power and brakes...but the question wasn't about a stock NSX.

I'm not an NSX "fanboy" at all, just answering the question asked. If you'd like to argue that a 911 is a fundamentally better setup car, by all means. I really don't care either way, I think they are both great cars, albeit the NSX is underrated as a drivers car.