Radiator Hose Came Undone WTF
#32
Wanted to update this thread as it's more appropriate for this measure. I took a piece of aluminum soda can and J-B Welded it with their strongest, but slowest setting stuff that I found at Walmart while there. It was a pain to work as I did not plan beforehand how I would keep it clamped down while it set. Here's the result after sitting from about 12 noon today. (It is 6 pm now).
#33
Interesting, I commend you with this and in improvising. Just definitely ghetto as you mentioned. Not sure if you could've applied some around the joint itself, a bead around it.. to further strengthen and in sealing it.
Last edited by Deezflip; 03-02-2020 at 08:01 PM.
#35
Thanks for the input guys! Yes, adding a weld bead around it sounds like a good idea that is actually on the instructions. Maybe I’ll do that tomorrow and let it set another day.
I need the engine to be more reliable. The car has been sitting for over a month now, maybe nearing 2. I’ll be so happy if it protects from sudden catastrophic coolant loss. That could definitely do some damage. (I discussed with my son his opinion on this plan. Being the smart teenager I know him to be he asked me what my concerns and pros were. My concern was creating a hot spot as it may act like an insulator. He then asked whether I thought the pros outweigh the cons. I believe so). I close the hood and that Shasta green is “out of site out of mind”. I do believe DogWood is correct that most of it, if not all, will be covered by the intake manifold/distributor as well.
I purchased/collected some Peak Global Lifetime Coolant. (It is not Porsche spec, but is a listed coolant for the car on the Peak website). They provide a cooling system warranty of $1000. If the housing to tube attachment does fail I’ll try to apply for it to cover replacement.
As far as I can deduce the system takes 28 L if anyone was wondering.
I’ll update as time goes on what develops....
I need the engine to be more reliable. The car has been sitting for over a month now, maybe nearing 2. I’ll be so happy if it protects from sudden catastrophic coolant loss. That could definitely do some damage. (I discussed with my son his opinion on this plan. Being the smart teenager I know him to be he asked me what my concerns and pros were. My concern was creating a hot spot as it may act like an insulator. He then asked whether I thought the pros outweigh the cons. I believe so). I close the hood and that Shasta green is “out of site out of mind”. I do believe DogWood is correct that most of it, if not all, will be covered by the intake manifold/distributor as well.
I purchased/collected some Peak Global Lifetime Coolant. (It is not Porsche spec, but is a listed coolant for the car on the Peak website). They provide a cooling system warranty of $1000. If the housing to tube attachment does fail I’ll try to apply for it to cover replacement.
As far as I can deduce the system takes 28 L if anyone was wondering.
I’ll update as time goes on what develops....
Last edited by jzchen; 03-02-2020 at 11:16 PM.
#36
I don’t think adding a bead around the original joint will help much in preventing the way it pops out. The aluminum brace seems like it has a much better chance. I will most likely add a bead around my makeshift brace as the edges aren’t uniformly attached.
#37
Two pictures of the results. I added more J-B Weld around the soda can strip, then waited another 24 hours. I finally reassembled the parts minus the pretty engine covers. Can't see it at all, but comforted it is there.
#39
I took the fuel rail/distributor off and removed the "y" shaped black coolant tube. I was planning on tackling a thermostat housing upgrade, but I'd still have to remove the water pump which is right in front of it. The belt has to come off and then you need to consider replacing that and possibly the belt tensioner. A whole bunch of parts to order, I figured this was worth a shot. I'm now driving it around but I still get the hot/warm start check engine light with P0068 and P1075 that I reported in the thread with that title. (I drove about a mile and stopped to get gas. Then drove a mile or so to my son's school and as soon as were turning into the parking lot got the chime and check engine light.)
I'll report how it holds up, though I must confess the car may not stay in out possession very much longer with all the troubles we keep experiencing.
I'll report how it holds up, though I must confess the car may not stay in out possession very much longer with all the troubles we keep experiencing.
#40
So, anyone use/interested in using EVANS waterless coolant to prevent this???
From SDS/MSDS research EVANS is pretty much pure ethylene glycol run without mixing in water. From people who use it the system pressure is so low that you can open it even when the engine is hot/warmed up.....
From SDS/MSDS research EVANS is pretty much pure ethylene glycol run without mixing in water. From people who use it the system pressure is so low that you can open it even when the engine is hot/warmed up.....
Last edited by 2012PTT; 06-04-2020 at 07:17 PM.
#41
I see a lot of coolants note a paint test where they test the corrosive effect to be neglibgle. But I would think that cleaning up would be part of the repair...
I looked as best as I could with a scope and our '13 has the same unbolted design! Different adhesive maybe, or just hasn't reached the age/mileage? Relatively I would expect '10, '11, '12, then '13 motors to have the failure in that order.
Have been hesitant to order the thermostat housing as I'm already sitting on top of a lot of parts and fluids...
I looked as best as I could with a scope and our '13 has the same unbolted design! Different adhesive maybe, or just hasn't reached the age/mileage? Relatively I would expect '10, '11, '12, then '13 motors to have the failure in that order.
Have been hesitant to order the thermostat housing as I'm already sitting on top of a lot of parts and fluids...
of course, it’s also possible that it’s already failed a 2nd time and been replaced with the new / better part, but I don’t have any post-warranty service records. I plan to get a camera down there sometime soon and figure out if I’m lucky enough that it’s already failed a 2nd time and been properly repaired or not
#42
No, I did not. I like the theory of lower pressure, and it makes sense, but looking at the MSDS it's just very pure ethylene glycol. I know users of it swear that it does not raise operating temperatures much, if at all, but the whole purpose of mixing water is to enhance/improve heat transfer, and hence cooling, of the engine.
I have a few things that would complicate that experiment now. I have JB Welded the metal hose that tends to come loose with a piece of aluminum soda can. With what I did making two passes with 48 hours total drying time I think it won't possibly break loose. It's rock hard, and luckily cool to the touch. I don't feel I need to worry that it's going to cause heat accumulation/hot spot. It, the metal hose, was still firmly attached when I tried to manipulate it, before I added the soda can JB Weld.
K-Seal. I confessed I put one bottle in. But after I figured out the capacity is about 28 L I realized one 8oz bottle is too little, so I added another one. (It's still leaking somewhere, but I don't know where beyond the filler cap it seems. I actually have a third bottle on hand but I don't want to risk possibly clogging something. This stuff would supposedly work on a leak between the pipe and the housing, hard parts,so I have no idea if this is what's helping me as well.
I bought a huge amount of Peak Global Lifetime 50/50 mix from Walgreens. 8 gallons which if my math was correct is enough for 30 L, per changing coolant instructions from Porsche Tech Info. I was hoping to change the coolant, after changing the "y" pipe which supposedly stops the leak, but never got around to it. (It did not stop leaking). I have been topping off with the Peak.
Suffices to say I'm really disappointed with reading about all these failures! I'm betting you guys are using the Porsche branded coolant? I mean Dogwood AND Yves both had a failure, it just didn't catastrophically pop out!
Last edited by jzchen; 06-04-2020 at 09:22 PM.
#44
So far I have not detected it come loose, and no seepage, original glue was fine when I last opened the intake manifold. Since it’s asymmetric the hose will tilt upwards on pressure and that will hopefully help provide friction to keep it in. The JB Weld is rock hard, cool to the touch, and it also will bear some load as I added a 2nd layer. Pretty permanent if you ask me. I will update if it ever breaks.
I do still have K-Seal flowing through the cooling system, supposedly it would work on such hard part leaks....
#45
I don’t know much about K Seal. Are there any downsides to using it? Would you suggest just preemptively pouring some in to prevent this failure for those with pre-2013 Turbos?
not to put you on the spot, just wondering if anyone knows more about this than me
not to put you on the spot, just wondering if anyone knows more about this than me